posted by Sam Richards
The problem we’re dealing with in 2009 is that we’re not asking people to THINK. We are feeding them information and few engage in dialogue with people who ask “why” and “how” and “if what you are saying is true, then what about…” Rusty thinking is what happens when we don’t sharpen our understanding of the world by conversing with people who are inclined to say to us “please tell me more about what you think about that.” These are, more often than not, people who have ideas that are different than those we espouse.
Imagine not having taken the opportunity to ride a bicycle for thirty years and suddenly somebody asks you to take an old, rusty bike out for a cruise. How do you imagine that you’d fare? Thirty years without ever being asked to spin those wheels and now you need to perform with all eyes upon you.
So we have this idea that people around us are thinking, that they’re truly using their brains. But have you listened to the conversations going on around you recently? No? Give them a listen now and then. There’s very little back and forth. I’d like to even be able to say that those are just opinions that people are throwing about but it’s hard to even hear the random, shallow, sophomoric ideas as “opinions.”
Okay, so really, the video below was put on the web by people who are critical of Sarah Palin and the people who support her. I’m putting it up, however, because it says nothing about Palin or her supporters and everything about Americans with rusty brains — including the millions of Obama fans who would answer similar questions about him and his policies in the same sort of awkward ways because they, too, drink in “fast food news” without being asked to give their brains a workout and interpret it.
And now…on to the show. And please, don’t laugh at them unless you have answers to the questions that don’t make you sound like a lost soul.
UPDATE: I’ve been reading some of the comments and I have to say I’m not entirely impressed. It’s the standard muckety-much about “my generation” and “people today” rounded out by “but I have to be honest and admit that I don’t know anything about politics.” C’mon people, how does it FEEL to be woefully and utterly ignorant about basic social and political issues? Take ownership, ya’ll. Lay it out there. Don’t grovel in it…but say something about what it means for you.
I have seen examples of this over and over again. It’s just pure ignorance and it is kind of sad. This is also part of the reason why politics is so messed up. Why do people follow politicians and how do people decide who to vote for? All last year during the presidential election these were questions running through my brain. I would say I am someone who knows a good amount about politics, or at least more than the average (that does not really say a lot). For example, before I vote for someone I look into their foreign policies, what they have done in the past, immigration views, fiscal policies, etc. I do not get how other people decide who to vote for. That video posted on the blog says it all. Last year when we were going through the presidential election time many people were talking about politics and their views. I would take part in these conversations probably about every day with adults and students. I knew what I was talking about, I knew what Obama stood by and what McCain stood by, but most people I talked to did not have a clue. I do not want to say it is this generation because who knows if fifty years ago it was the same way. Moreover, I completely agree with Sam, people are not being asked to think. People just hear things from the screwed up media, their friends, and their parents and so on and they believe it. Nobody asks questions, like why I should believe this or what could this lead too. This kind of ticks me off when I see it happen. Actually it really ticks me off. It makes me feel like people don’t care anymore and they do not want use their own brains to think. So if they hear something from any source they will trust it without any questions. What is the point of having a brain if we are never going to use it and ask questions? What makes me even more mad is when someone tries to tell me something they heard on the news or from another source and automatically tell me it is correct. How ignorant are people that they do not realize everyone is biased, especially the media. People will only tell you the facts or falsify the facts to make their own case look better. Therefore, you cannot trust anyone’s opinion besides your own. But people do not live this way and it is a problem. It is hard to find people that really think for themselves and fully interpret what they hear. And if people think that it is only Palin’s followers that do this, they are very wrong. If anything Obama’s supporters are even worse.
[Reply]
I can’t say enough about disappointed I am with my generation regarding political intelligence and knowledge of current events. At the same time, I’m not really surprised either. When was the last time that history was part of a standardized test in high school? From grade school and high school we are taught that English and mathematics are the most helpful to our development, with all other things taking a back seat. We gain our political knowledge second hand through illegitimate sources of media (Colbert Show, The Daily Show). We never truly hear politics from a unbiased source. We hear politics from CNN, or Fox News, or the aforementioned illegitimate sources. We collect the opinions of others, and never really think for ourselves. When was the last time that you took a political affiliation test and answered questions to find out where you stand in the political arena? The problem is that we can’t think for ourselves and it’s much easier to be spoon-fed our political beliefs than to look them up ourselves and do our own research.
A perfect example was last year’s presidential election. We had masses of individual young voters who were blinded by the glitz and glare that was Barack Obama. They were impressed by his charisma, his answers to our problems and his constant shouts of change. However, these young voters didn’t look at Obama’s political platform. They didn’t realize that Obama’s platform was hallow, and basically a presidential bid that was motored by promises of change, and nothing else. They voted for Barack Obama the rockstar, not Barack Obama the politician. The problem is, that our country needs Barack Obama the politician. The man who wants to bring immediate change, and not change that will take effect four to five years down the line.
When it comes down to it, political affiliation is like religion. When we discuss religion we clam up and end every argument with well these are me beliefs and you can’t change that. Unfortunately, political affiliation has the same problem. A conservative can be proven wrong in every sense of the word, but he will deny it because at the end of the day he needs to stay by party lines. This inability to accept wrong prevents us from going as a people, and I believe it is a primary reason why political intelligence is low these days. People think that their political beliefs don’t have to change, that they can have these beliefs even if they are proven wrong. This creates people saying stupid things in conversation or not knowing anything at all. Political intelligence is simply not a need anymore to the American public. It’s a shame, but something that won’t change in a government that doesn’t require intelligent people, just votes.
[Reply]
On the topic of being ignorant about political and social issues, it’s easy for everyone to point a finger and say “you don’t know anything.” It seems everyone nowadays is “anti” something or “pro” something, but can never back it up. During the 2008 elections, many college students nationwide became highly involved. All over campus, people saying things like “Obama is a socialist” and “McCain is going to ruin this country,” etc. etc. No one could back it up. People around me would get into arguments daily about the elections, but none of the talk was about their platforms or policies, it was all about age, race, and sex. Everyone is so quick to jump on a bandwagon and go along for a ride, when they actually have NO idea where the wagon is going. The majority of people get their facts from someone they heard it from, or some unreliable source. I have met very few people on campus that have actually done the research themselves and know what they are talking about, so that when they do have an argument, they can back up their statements. Alas, it becomes a battle of 2 idiots shouting back and forth about absolutely nothing of importance. How are we to blame though, when every step you take someone else is trying to shove propaganda down your throat? Like on voting day, if you’re on your way to the HUB to vote for Obama, and people are outside trying to give you a McCain pin, as if that’s going to change your mind. But then again…does it?
I didn’t vote. Purposely. And everyone immediately wanted to know why. “You didn’t vote!? What? Why!?” It’s not because I’m lazy, it’s because I knew very little about the candidates policies and hadn’t spent the time to research them to formulate a vote. I also don’t pretend to know things about politics. I’m a bio major, and have very, very little interest in politics and elections. So no, I didn’t vote, and when people say you should have voted just to say you voted, I look at them in awe. I think you should have to take an exam on the candidates to be eligible to vote. So Sam says we don’t think enough, and I completely agree. The clip on Palin showed a group of people ready to vote Palin into office in a heartbeat, but didn’t know a thing about her policies. When did choosing the president of our country become a popularity vote? Before Obama, I don’t remember the last time our president was on the cover of every celebrity magazine, following their lives as if they were the Osbournes.
[Reply]
This story is definitely nothing new. Probably 9 out of 10 people you ask randomly in America would know nothing or little about any particular issue. What you will hear as a response is exactly like what you saw in the video, they will spout some sound bite that they heard on television and try to link it to something that it usually does not really connect with. As a political science major I almost have to stay up on the news and the issues and try to do so. I don’t view it as tedious or work because I enjoy having at least some knowledge about the world around me. And what I have always been frustrated with is the complacency most Americans have towards politics and the news. Many people I have encountered don’t just have an “I don’t care about politics” attitude but rather are hostile towards it. When I tell people I am a political science major I usually get responses like “damn, sorry to hear that,” or just simply a look that I perceive as “why would you want to do that?” And some people respond by talking about the anger they have towards politicians. AND THESE ARE THE SAME PEOPLE THAT DON’T KNOW ANYTHING if you ask them. That’s probably the most frustrating part, the people that are most angry and most set in their ways usually, if you ask them specific questions, have no idea about what they are talking about.
And I carry that into how I can’t believe someone could possibly agree with Republicans or Democrats on all of their issues. I personally can’t agree with even half of either party’s platforms and with most of their policies I can find a chunk of what I don’t like. I’ve always held the belief that if anyone actually researches into most areas of debate i.e. healthcare, immigration, the wars in Iraq/ Afghanistan they will not agree with either side but will rather land somewhere in the middle. And that is why I am an Independent. People like to joke that independents are fence sitters that can’t make up their minds. And I always respond with that you must be crazy to be anywhere but the middle, either extreme is usually always ridiculous.
So that was just a brief description of my frustration with peoples’ ignorance towards politics and their reluctance to actually do anything about it. And I feel the real problem lies with that last part, how people seem to have this strong reluctance to do anything about it. Most people seem to almost not want to “be troubled” with the burden of actually backing up their claims with some real thought and analysis. This could be a byproduct of our information age where anything can be found quickly and easily and people now expect everything, including very complicated social issues, to be available in the same format. And that format has been graciously filled by most news outlets. Sound bites have been the “solution” that many news networks have used to keep the attention of our nation. And because it is on the news, many people take it piecemeal as the truth that shouldn’t be questioned. I feel that mentality is what is making America so rash and compulsive, they hear one little thing about something and they are all for it if it makes sense to them without looking at any other side or actually trying to decide on their own. That is the problem.
[Reply]
I don’t know that much about politics but…… no I’m just kidding I’m not going to start like that after reading the update. However, the fact that people feel the need to say that is enough of a phenomenon on its own. One would think that in stating an opinion, an individual would want to sound as educated on the subject as possible in order to sound credible. Of course, maybe “I don’t pay attention to politics” is a way to lower expectations for that individual’s ideas so their ideas are looked at less critically.
I understand Sam’s concept of fast food news, because whenever I try to debate politics with my dad he asks me, “And what channel did you get that from”. More times than not he’s right, I find myself quoting things I hear in popular media and not searching for more information. I would imagine that I am not the only one with this problem. In the Sarah Palin book signing video, the people that did respond to questions seem to spout of talking points directly from fox news friends or Sean Hannity. I’ll stop myself from ragging on the “fair and balanced” news network, but I think anyone who gets their news from only one place is at risk of receiving bias.
This is going to get a little political which is not the point of this journal, but I was thinking about what some of the other journal entries were saying and wanted to put a point out there. On one hand, Democrats saw Obama as the face of change in the presidential election. By contrast, this would mean that McCain was more old fashioned or that he wanted to keep things the same. By contrast, people are now complaining that Obama hasn’t made any significant change. This could possibly be attributed to the weak unity of the Democratic Party, they are having trouble voting together to outnumber the near unanimous decisions of Republicans. Now, looking at these facts, who are the good guys here? The ones who can’t get their act together long enough to pass a bill, or the ones who choose not to change anything with the power they have. Now, this is all speaking in generalities and my perception of how people view opposing parties, but it does seem to come down to “the lesser of two evils”, which isn’t ideal by any standard.
In the eyes of the founding fathers, being an educated voter is the duty of every American. This is one thing that surprised me about the video of flag waving Palin supporters talking about back-to-basics values that they couldn’t explain. In a time when the internet is at your fingertips I find it rather bothersome that someone couldn’t be bothered to look up the facts. Overall, it is not only the republicans or Palin supporters who are to blame, but all parties are guilty of uneducated voting.
[Reply]
I was actually going to submit this video a few weeks ago when I first saw it. I was excited to see it posted on the blog. While it doesn’t seem to have to do much with race (except for the fact that there didn’t seem to be any minorities and naturalization got brought up), I can’t help but comment. It would be much easier if I had a transcript. First, the creators of this video posted on the information page of this video on YouTube that they 1: didn’t ‘cherry-pick’, 2: they accept that there are Obama supporters who are talking-point driven as well, which there are. I’ve met a number of ‘liberals’ who just have a textbook agenda. I disagree with Sam on a few point he made on this blog post. First, he compared these people to those who might ride a bike for the first time in 30 years. These people don’t strike me like that. These people seem confident enough in their ‘opinions’ and ‘facts’ about policies, especially the two women who are particularly condescending: “This is America. I’m an American. We don’t have Czars in America” (forgetting that the loose definition of czar in the American context goes all the way back to FDR, some even think back to President Wilson). Most of these people have a few attributes in common: that they are political enough to be reinvigorated to remember the good old days of Reagan (which is the populist imagery that Palin evokes), yet not political enough to know anything beyond the bullet-points. Sam is absolutely right about one thing: our ignorance (both left and right) is a direct result of the way we get our information. This is ‘fast-food’ news in bullet-point format (like the tickers at the bottom of the screen) filled with little more than buzz-words such as ‘socialism,’ ‘abortion,’ ‘illegal aliens,’ ‘liberal elites/media,’ ‘getting back to basics’ and ‘big government’ (all we’re missing is ‘evil empire’ and we’ve got Reagan v. 2.0). It seems there are two types of answers this group of people: either something they completely made up, or the bullet-points they studied watching Faux News. Great examples of the former are: fairness, politically correctness, realness, making a difference in policies they’ve never even thought about before, standing for ‘real’ America, while some better examples for the latter are: cutting spending (ALL OF IT PLEASE), lower taxes, a more anchapuhnewial, condusive enviruhment, and cap-and-trade. I especially like the cap and trade name drop because I had no idea what it was either. But what sets us apart is that I consider myself somewhat informed, and when I don’t fully understand an “issue”, I admit it, unlike these people who are essentially just pretending to know, and some even being arrogant about it, only to be ultimately stumped when asked “why” or “can you explain that further.” After all, these people volunteered to be asked questions. All I can say is “be prepared to answer tough questions.”
[Reply]
Those Rusty Brains
As I am watching the video of the Sarah Palin fans being interviewed I couldn’t help but remember all of the bickering that went on during the last election about the two candidates Obama and McCain. People who were uninformed and were simply being utterly un-insightful to the conversation with their remarks were speaking out and trying to get their voices heard, which led into more of a who can yell the loudest battle rather than an actual political debate. Nobody knew what they were talking about, not a single person could declare more than one policy that their candidate or their opponent represented. It was embarrassing and was futile to try and have a legitimate conversation with somebody else. Much like the man who accused Obama of outlawing abortion, people were building up stories that they wanted to hear so that they could justify their beliefs in their candidate. People are too selective when it comes to gathering information, and I don’t believe that this selective hearing has anything to do with a person’s characteristics. It doesn’t matter what state you are in, what religion, race or creed you follow and it doesn’t matter how old you are, we are all somewhat if not completely selective listeners. At the age of the average voting college student we seem to base our political opinions off of the ideas and words presented to us by others around us, especially our parents. Though we don’t want to admit it we still listen to what our parents are saying and more times than not the first time you vote, it is for whatever party your parents are for due to the fact that this is the party you have been hearing about how great it is and how the others are the enemy of the nation for most of your adult life. People are letting others decide for them, which eliminates the whole concept of free choice completely. Why are we so susceptible to being brainwashed by the people and media around us? Everyone thinks they know what is right because all they have been hearing is the same nonsensical drivel from the same uniformed people. If you want proof just watch the people in the video. Nobody really has a good answer let alone are close to having the ultimately correct answer. Opinions are like noses ever ones got one and they all smell. People love to be right and what better way of convincing ourselves that we are right then talking out of our asses and nobody telling us that our opinions are skewed from the truth. People are so ill informed that they can’t disagree with your opinions because they themselves don’t know any better. All we are spewing out is our own personal rotten opinions. So who do we blame for our lack of knowledge? We surely can’t point the finger back at ourselves; because then somebody would have to admit that they weren’t the second coming of Christ that has been sent from heaven to help America out of its dark times. As Sam said in class earlier in the week we all see ourselves as the special little guy or girl that our parents told us we were when we were little. Nobody in regular society is the almighty genius that is going to lead America to the promise land, if you were then somebody a long time ago would have told you that you really have good ideas and you would be talking on TV, but if that is not you than do yourself a favor and actually research topics before you form and blurt out your insane opinions. Twenty minutes of research will not only make you appear smarter but may actually help you pick a leader for our country on your own, rather than having to fall back on meaningless stereotypes and accusations.
[Reply]
Naturally, a lot of people feel that this video is hilarious. Of course, you stick a microphone in anyone’s face and they probably won’t be able to answer on the spot. That being said, the video is honestly more worrying to me. I don’t know much about politics. I say that straight out, and I know that. But then again, I admit to it. When I can, I do try and actually learn about the world that I’m living in.
People will always be stupid. They always have, and honestly, they always will. Like Sam said in lecture on Tuesday, people consistently think that they are smarter and better than they really are. When I used to live overseas, you see a lot of very ignorant people. Maybe you just become a little bit more knowledgeable about different subjects, so certain things stick out to you. For instance, when I lived in Japan, a friend of one of my British friends asked me “oh, you live in Japan? Do you walk to China a lot?” Over break, my family was playing catchphrase, and my uncle got the clue “Greek Gods, and his hint for us to get it was, “it’s a city in Turkey”. People seem to try to be less smart than I know they are. People are just smarter about different things.
The prompt mentions that a lot of people are talking about “their” generation being the problem. Honestly, stop being so self-centered, people have been stupid for millennia, and they will be forever. Do you think that the average person knew things about politics in any time in the past; do you really think that they would actually be able to tell you much more than people nowadays? What I find depressing is not that we are more stupid than in years past – actually if you listen to psychological personality test by Fleishman and the like, they have to update the age groups you test at because people keep scoring higher and higher. But that people are not smarter in reality. We seem to show more proficiency in IQ tests, but people still focus on things that actually have no bearing on our lives. We watch The Hills, we vote for our favorite Top Chef. Why is it that more often people discuss Farmville than they do international Politics? It’s kind of a shame. Actually, Madagascar has tried to bridge the politics – entertainment gap by creating a comic strip that updates the public as to what is going on in the government at any given time. This kind of reminds me of the video skits of the constitutional bill “sittin’ on Capitol Hill” who sings about the legal system in the US. Honestly, if it wasn’t for that little cartoon bill I would have no idea about anything about American government.
I complain about people being stupid, but I really am the same way, but it does annoy me and I do try. I suppose there is some merit to those who really show no drive to learn about their country or their world. To be completely content in yourself is commendable.
On another note, did anyone else notice that all of the women seemed to look like Sarah Palin clones?
[Reply]
Reflecting upon Sam’s post, I am intrigued and embarrassed to know that I too fall under the category of non-thinkers. In typical human fashion, I like to view myself as more informed than others and relatively intelligent. However, my innate ability to perform cognitively does not reflect my ability to actively think and engage in what is going on around me.
Listening to conversations is very telling about how and what people are thinking about. It is actually quite disturbing to overhear conversations going on among my peers. When eavesdropping, I am often astonished to overhear the asinine conversations revolving around superficial drama void of any inkling of current events. If current events are discussed, they are often filled with misinformation and loosely based viewpoints made into pseudo opinions. Generally, I laugh or roll my eyes as those I find less scholarly. Yet, I now realized that I am indeed a perpetrator of this intellectual crime.
Now that I think of it, I have not had any sort of intellectual argument in quite some time. And while I wish that I could engage in more, I am also hesitant to do so because I know that I am uninformed in most topics. I have not paid attention enough to be armed with the ammo to have an effective and well-formed argument with anyone on a variety of topics. And that makes me feel dumb. It is rare for me to ask what people think about certain topics or for me to even ask myself what I think about certain topics because I am so concerned with where I have to go and what I have to do next. I don’t bother to deal with things irrelevant to my life. However, upon reflection, I realize that it is all relevant to my life. International politics, global warming, H1N1 and so much more have the potential to have dramatic events on my life, yet I am completely unaware how they are affecting me.
Yes, it is certainly much easier to blame my ignorance on everything that is going on around me in terms of today’s societal values instead of my own laziness. The “fast food” ideology we have embraced in the United States transcends from the news into education. In today’s education world we are simply dumping knowledge into students with the hopes that they will be able to repeat knowledge on the assessments we deem important. We have come to associate knowledge and skill with the ability to repeat facts and perform repetitions of the skills the government and society have deemed important. We no longer ask students to think and form opinions, in fact public and private education values conformity over individuality and the exploration of other viewpoints.
While this may seem to be a reasonable explanation, there needs to be a level of personal responsibility. Although it is embarrassing to reflect about how little I know about what is going on around me and how much great information there is that I am missing out on, I cannot pass this ignorance onto the faults of society. In the self-absorbed pattern of life that I have developed, I feel like I do not have the time to devote to such petty principles such as knowledge. But if I could take my time away from the wasteful uses of my time, I feel that I would find the fruits of enlightenment and knowledge.
Taking the time to reflect on what Sam wrote, I can acknowledge what I am doing wrong. I feel a certain way about being compared to the people in the video who sound stupid. But I know that if I was put in the same position, people would probably say the same about me. I think there is something very powerful in comparing our lack of thinking with riding a rusty bike: we do not pay attention to our unmotivated and insincere efforts to think, and when asked to do so, we realize we cannot and fail with all eyes upon us.
[Reply]
When I first seen this video I just could not believe the words that were coming out of these people mouths. Are they really serious? You want someone like Sarah Palin to be our President when she got followers like these idiots speaking about what she is going to do for our country when they do not even know what she stands for…I think that is so funny. Over the last year Palin has been through a lot. She is a former Alaska governor and Republican Vice President candidate, released her new book Going Rogue: An American Life on Nov. 17. Palin’s book title came from a expression used by a dissatisfied John McCain aide to describe her going off-message during the presidential campaign. Many people like Michiko Kakutani, a writer for The New York Times, believes that this book is not directed at Democrats or liberals or the news media, but at the McCain campaign.Despite Palin’s 413-page book being a best seller, her book still received mixed reviews from The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times.
“All in all Ms. Palin emerges from “Going Rogue” as an eager player in the blame game, ungrateful to the McCain campaign for putting her on the national stage.” said Kakutani.
The day before her book was released, Palin did an interview on the Oprah Winfrey show to talk about her book and her future in politics. Palin was asked a wide range of questions about the statements she made about running for President in 2012 to the Thanksgiving dinner invitation she said she offered Levi Johnston, the father of her daughter Bristol’s baby. “It’s heartbreaking to see the road that Levi Johnston has taken and that the soon-to-be Playgirl model hasn’t seen his baby in awhile,” said Palin during the Oprah interveiw.Palin was also asked about her banning books like Harry Potter from the Wasilla, Alaska public library when she was Mayor. She responded by saying that it was untrue and that the book was written after she left office.
“For the record Ms. Palin was mayor of Wasilla from 1996 to 2002. Peter Grier said, a blogger for the Christian Science monitor. “Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, the first volume of J.K. Rowling’s popular series, was published in the US in 1998.”
Many people believed that during the interview Oprah tried not to be too soft on Palin because her more liberal viewers would be upset but she also did not want to be too hard on Palin for her more conservative viewers would be upset. “I don’t think it was wise for Oprah to give Sarah Palin an opportunity for more publicity and self-promotion, said Jess Kress, a follower of the Oprah Winfrey show, “There are a lot of people who can’t see through her and the more someone is thrust in their face, the more they seem to believe that person could be a legitimate candidate. This is a country that elected George W. Bush not once, but twice.”
[Reply]
There are always people that are going to fit this mold and people who actually care about the people they are voting for and will make an effort to find out about them before choosing to support them. There are plenty of people in this world, democrats and republicans who take a stand or opinion on a candidate, donate money to their campaign but couldn’t name one policy of theirs. I’m not saying I am some big political activist but before I do anything I make sure I know enough about it so I am able to make an informed decision. I don’t think it’s our generation that this problem started to occur. I think this had always been a problem and probably will always be a problem. There are always going to be people who jump on the bandwagon even though they have no idea what the meaning is behind it. Because their will always be people who are lazy and just don’t care. Some of the youths are more educated than most adults so it’s ridiculous to say the youths are the ones who are bringing this about. Obama won the election because of the youth vote I am not justifying this because I think more than half of these people should not have even voted because they know nothing about the candidate and only voted for him because he’s an African American. The you tube clip of the Sarah Palin’s book signing showed how stupid her supporter’s looked. They are almost as stupid as her, they have no idea what she stands for or any of her policies. Everyone has different passions and things they are interested in. Some favor politics but those people should know something about it to form an opinion on it. I think there is a lack of good conversation between people. Its so on the surface and people just spit out opinions with nothing to back it up. If people took the time to learn about what other people really had to say and other cultures they would be able to make informed opinions and not look like such an idiot when trying to support something that they think they believe in. I think rusty thinking happen quite often because many people don’t know a lot about anything but that doesn’t make them stupid. As long as they have knowledge about things that are important to them that’s all that really matters. We talked about in class how people don’t try to obtain more information on things because they think there better than other people. This may be part of the reason but this is not necessarily true all the time. There are many reasons why people are not knowledgeable and why conversations are on the surface.
[Reply]
This post could not have come at a better time. Some good friends and I just sat down the other day to discuss this exact issue. Collectively we have noticed more and more that people in general have become so absorbed in petty things, that they are not using their energy to think about real issues that are affecting the world around us. I’m not quite sure if this is a new problem for society, or we have been so consumed with petty things ourselves up until this point that we never noticed others behavior. To be honest it is probably the latter.
But nonetheless, this is a huge problem in the world. Men, women and especially teenagers absorb themselves in their looks and relationships with others. And I know this because I was a true victim when I was in high school. I remember consuming all of my time and effort into stupid drama with my friends. Or worrying about how I look and buying the right clothes that everybody would like. It was undeniably exhausting! And the worst part was that my mind was so full of useless information that I had no desire to think about the issues that were affecting other people in the world.
Being in college has taught me a lot about myself. And a huge part of my learning experience has been about taking part in the important matters of our society. I have definitely learned to let go of the petty, insignificant issues because at the end of the day they are not going to make a difference in my life. And why waste all of my time being selfish when I can help make a difference in the world. I know that sounds all high and mighty, but I do not mean it in that type of way. What I am saying is that I think I have learned a big part about growing up and taking responsibility for myself.
It just surprises me that more people have not learned this lesson yet. I’d like to think of myself as an average intelligent person. How have I figured this out and other people haven’t? I mean why waste your time. Get on board and worry about the important things in life! It makes me feel good at the end of the day that I know I have made intelligent and well thought through decisions about who to vote for in elections. Every election counts and that’s something that I don’t think others really believe. I know a lot of people who refused to vote in the presidential election because they figured that one little vote wouldn’t make much of a difference. That is just absurd and lazy! Who we choose to run our country is extremely important because it is going to affect almost every aspect of our lives. That is why I do not understand when people just take what they hear on the news and use that to define their opinions about the candidates. Guess what, the news is biased! You need to do the research on your own and form your own decisions or else it is a waste of time to even vote.
[Reply]
The level of knowledge demonstrated by the majority of the people being interviewed was not only unimpressive but an embarrassing testament to how fervently some people will back ideas, people, or policies that they know nothing about. I by no means claim to be an expert on politics, or to understand all the policies being debated on Capitol hill. But I’m also not standing in a line in support of some politician, clutching their book, which an outside observer would assume had been read, and arguing that they are the change our country needs. To find me waiting in the cold in such a line just to meet some figure for probably thirty seconds of generic conversation, would mean that I was passionate about the topic, and would understand it!
It’s disturbing to think of how the masses, demonstrated by this sampling of average Americans, grant power to people and provide the public support for policies they do not understand. It doesn’t seem like much of a stretch to compare such actions occurring now, to those that allowed such crazed individuals as Adolf Hitler to assume power in the past; people desire their problems to be fixed, and in their need turn to an amiable public figure or politician, whose motives, goals, policies, and ideas are unknown. The ignorant masses, using the power granted to us all by our own Constitution, give power to someone they do not understand, and as history demonstrated, will bring down upon us all the consequences and undesirable results of such inattention. It happened in Germany, whose population suffered unemployment, inflation beyond anything else seen in this century, food shortages, lack of resources, and the humiliation of a once powerful empire reduced to shattered country put on parole by the rest of Europe. While comparing the atrocities of the Third Reich to our current political theatre is overdramatic and entirely inaccurate, the methods by which the former gained power are echoed by the attitudes of people such as those in the video. And the possibility of who or what, in terms of policy, could come to power because of such ignorance is frightening.
Part of the problem in why people might back politicians or policies they don’t understand is the sheer amount of knowledge thrown at us in this ‘information age’. The amount of current issues being debated, which span the gamut of conserving the rain forest, to stopping starvation in Africa, to the possibility of a nuclear Iran, to unemployment, to finding another habitable planet, each have their own public ‘flag-bearer’ and endless amounts of research, news, changes they are striving for, and political advancements to keep track of. Being interested and following the updates of even a few of these issues demands an enormous amount of time, attention, and focus on the part of the individual. And many people simply do not have the time. So they do what they can to support their cause, and perhaps that manifests itself in the form of providing support to those figures who we perceive to support our beliefs, and who devote their time to advancing such beliefs or issues.
[Reply]
In regards to the video, I’m tired of seeing conservatives represented in the media by people who are ignorant of politics, are unable to assemble their thoughts on camera, lack a formal education, or have obvious holes in their arguments, e.g. Sean Hannity. As a liberal, I’ve almost given up open political debate against people I encounter because people seem so passionate, sometimes even hateful about things they don’t understand due to a lack of education or conceptual grasp of the topics at hand. I can say this confidently and hopefully with credibility because I was captain of my high school debate team and from that, learned not to have a strong opinion about something which I do not know and to pursue an end with the means of knowledge and understanding.
Even without a conceptual understanding of current events, I’m sure we all have emotional reactions to what we see on the news or with our own eyes, but I expect that my emotional reactions can feasibly by contradicted with minimally biased factually based information. That meaning, I will not have a heated argument with someone about my gut feeling that Barack Obama is a good man and will inevitably lead this country in the right direction because I know my emotions are subjective by nature. If someone can make a valid argument for why his policies are ineffective than I cannot argue that with my emotions and instinct since I am not the Oracle at Delphi nor am I Socrates whom she deemed that are there was none wiser; my instincts do not equate to truth.
I agree with Sam; it seems that nowadays, when people form their opinions, they do so equipped with rusty brains rather than a sharp wit. Emotion cannot argue with fact, reason, and logic just as Sam mentioned science cannot argue with faith and vice versa. It seems as though when people have a debate, they aim to win rather than come to an educational conclusion of what is right. Politics has become that same uneducated debate – liberal vs. conservative, Democrat vs. Republican. I support bipartisan rule in government, but there is a cycle of opposition in which one side pursues emotion and the other pursues reason. Right now, it is the liberal Democrat side that has chosen reason, but when faced with emotion, it chooses concise long-winded arguments, which though effective in bureaucratic rule, bore all to ignorance and are no match for raw though often uneducated emotion, e.g. the included video of Sarah Palin supporters and Fox News.
The reason why emotion is so heavily involved in politics is that we want likeable government representatives similar to the way we want likeable celebrities on TV. Furthermore, in order to have educated discussions on politics and leave emotion at the door, we need to have a reasonable understanding of what we want, what we support, and why; then we have to choose government representatives that best correspond to our stances, which can be proven by little more than what politicians have done in their experience, what they say they will do, and the degree to which those two things agree. With an understanding of these six areas, we don’t have to resort to supporting people to run our government, the framework of our society, because they are more likeable, appeal to our instinctive nature of gathering in herds with those similar to us, i.e. choosing Sarah Palin because she is white or Barack Obama because he’s black, etc.; we can instead choose people who will logically pursue what we want and are experienced and knowledgeable enough to know how to do it. Politics then becomes rather simple in a democracy, reduced to: What does the majority want, and using history and theory, how do we get it? We can eliminate everything in between. Unfortunately, that robs modern media of bickering, which attracts viewers and readers, and so to remove the in-between, the waste that is modern politics, would be unprofitable and anti-capitalist. In the end, wealth, which is most efficiently attained via capitalism, trumps democracy.
Democracy in itself is flawed because we choose elected officials rather than electing policies ourselves, i.e. the use of direct democracy and propositions, because the general public has been deemed not educated enough to choose the policies that are best for us, but if we are not educated enough to choose the right policies, how can we be educated enough to choose elected officials to pursue the policies we are unable to choose ourselves?
The answer to inefficient emotional politics like anything else including the race relations is education, understanding, and openness, i.e. don’t let our brains get rusty!
[Reply]
After watching this video I was very surprised to see the little people know about people and politics. Many of these people standing out there were just voting for the fun of it. When they were asked questions about Sarah Palin, they really didn’t know how to answer they were just there for the book signing. This is very sad because like Sam said people are just fed things, and most people believe it and they do not do their own research. This is how many people are convinced into doing many things that they don’t even have a clue about. This in other words is just saying that people are just taking advantage of the ignorance of the other people. This is very sad especially to the United States and the society because if people are just voting because other people are telling them to vote; how do we know if whoever is winning is really the best person that is supposed to be winning. This not only effects them but it effects the whole country. For example when we vote for the president we usually do our research before voting to see who Is the best candidate for our presidency. Obviously we are going to vote for the person that will do the most positive changes to our lives. But if we have people like these on the video voting without knowing anything, this could really be a problem with the society, they might be voting for the wrong person. So in my opinion I think people should stop jumping on the band wagon and stop following other people just because they might sound convincing. People everywhere are always going to do whatever it takes to win a competition. So I think that these people should start doing some research that way they will prevent other people from taking advantage of them and also by doing this they will be able to make the better choice which would benefit the society. Much of these people don’t use their brains because of laziness fo doing their own research. Many of these people relay on the media such as the television, the newspaper and or the radio to do their research for them. But how many times have you actually stopped and thought about that if the information that this being displayed is actually real? Many people usually never stop to think this way; they just take in whatever they are told. In my opinion people should be more questionable about everything they hear because now a days you never know who is actually telling the truth or who is lying. And the only way to prevent this from happening like I said is doing the research and actually finding the facts by yourself and stop believing everything people say.
[Reply]
After reading and listening to the blog about “Rusty Brains” and the comments that people were making at the Sarah Palin book signing, I can say probably this one thing that gets under my skin the most is when people are having a discussion and have no clue what they are even talking about. They do not know the facts, they do not have any information or evidence in what they are saying and it truly pisses me off. I believe that before anyone opens their mouth to speak on a topic or issue, they should at least know the background of the issue and have reinforcements to back up whatever they are claiming to be saying. When topics about politics and government are brought up into a discussion, if I do not know the issue or have enough information to add in an educated manner, I will not say anything because then you look ignorant for what you are saying. But believe me, if a topic is being talked about and I know many aspects on the topic, I will have no problem in calling you out on what you saying.
Many of the things that the people in this video were saying were so wrong. I cannot even think of a different word because sometimes my mouth would literally fall open to what they were saying. Like the woman who said we Americans, as in white people, come first, and all the others, meaning people of color or immigrants or people from other countries, they come last. ARE YOU KIDDING ME!!! It was also blatantly obvious that these people had no clue what Sarah Palin even stands for on issues. When he would ask them what they thought about her policies, no one could say one policy that Sarah Palin wanted to put into effect if she was elected. It drives me crazy when people try to speak intelligently, but end up looking like a fool because they do not know about the issue at hand. I have this same conversation with my boyfriend all the time. He will say something that I do not agree with or will say something really rude. I usually try really hard not to get mad or upset with him because I understand that people think a certain way because of where they are from or how they were brought up. Even with taking all of those factors into consideration, some of thoughts and ideas are so narrow minded and I could not even fathom the idea of someone believing those things. I think a lot of it has to do with people not being told all of the facts and told the other point of view to get them to think about it differently. That is what we all need to do. Before we start running our mouths about something, we need to be educated on the topic and look at from other perspectives to fully understand all sides of the argument.
[Reply]
After reading the journal, I skimmed through some of the posts to see how some of my peers had interpreted that data. I was kind of shocked to the responses. I believe Sam did a pretty good job and disclaiming that this video was not posted as an attack on Sarah Palin but instead picked to highlight the lack of knowledge so much of the United States has in respect to politics and hot topic issues. The fact is that people on both sides of the political spectrum fall into this, regardless of who they are backing. Being affiliated with a political party makes people think that the work is done for you when a candidate is picked to represent it. However, that is far from the truth. Just because you tend to agree with most of the issues of a party does not mean that you will agree with the issues of the candidate selected. I have met many people who consider themselves either Democratic or Republican and have beliefs or ideals different than other people in their party. Not everyone is going to agree on everything which is one of the reasons why people should really inform themselves about the views and ideals of the candidates to see who really stands for what you believe, not just looking for the (D) or (R) at the end of their name. The likelihood of people doing that though is very, very slim. Present day media makes it so easy to not think about candidate’s ideals, especially since all of it is usually skewed towards one side of the spectrum. Obviously, the conservative is more likely to watch Fox News since it solidifies what he or she believes. I think it would be more beneficial to watch the station opposite of what you believe to get a more rounded view on topics, instead of watching a program where you would not question the thoughts or ideas of the person in charge or someone you are thinking about voting for.
However, with all of this being said, I really do not think that people really care too much about these “hot topic” issues to study the candidates and delve into the reasons behind their beliefs. Take abortion for example. How much does abortion really affect our daily lives? I’m sure we could all find someone we know who has had some experience with abortion, but how does that really impact our lives? Most people have very heated opinions about it, regardless of which side of the issue you stand on. There was one group who came up here this semester and set up a huge display about abortion outside of the Forum and protested it. People say they feel strongly about it, but for most of them, I’d like to call a bluff. Yeah, you may feel one way or another but you do not care enough to know what the current laws are or what changes are being proposed by different parties or candidates. This happens with all issues, and I think it is because most people are just fine with how things are. They are fine with the overall government and how it is run. Sure, people will always want to change things but not many people want some sort of drastic change. So to them, it does not matter on a day to day basis whether a specific spending measure is cut or the abortion law is altered or some illegal immigrants are granted citizenship. People will always disagree with certain government aspects and there are always those people who just love to argue, but I think that overall, most people are satisfied or content with the current situations to not learn more about it. This would then be why they can just follow someone without really knowing what he or she stands for or plans to do. If the person’s place on the political spectrum matches yours, there is no thinking required. I don’t think we just care enough to learn more about it. We’re content with our rusty brains.
[Reply]
Ignorance has no political allegiance. Many people on both sides of the political spectrum seem to choose a candidate based more on personal likeability than on actual issues. Unfortunately, the person you like the most is not always the person who will have your best interests at heart or be the most capable of leading. A big part of the problem is people’s unwillingness to listen to conflicting points of view, which leads to a tendency to only hear news that supports what you want to hear.
The Palin supporters who were unable to cite her stance on any particular issue are no different than the Obama supporters who cite his desire for “change.” Though Palin supporters, and some of them rightfully so, have become a symbol of mockery for the level of ignorance that is pervasive across America, they are by no means the only guilty parties. For many people, politics are an aspect of life that they would rather avoid. However, they still feel that it is their civic duty and right to vote, even if they are uninformed on the relevant issues. As a result, many people seem to be persuaded by how a politician says something rather than what they actually say. For example, many found Palin to be “refreshing” because of her down-home speech and demeanor, while many more gravitated toward Obama because of his intellectual fortitude and charismatic speeches. However, neither of these inclinations is rooted in any type of critical thinking.
Ignorance is a force that builds upon itself. Once it takes shape, it is hard to break down. As more people choose to close their minds and become complacent, constructive dialogue comes to a halt. This is particularly draining for those in society who are working to promote the importance of understanding the issues at hand and seek to engage others intellectually. The result is the formation of an “us” and “them”: those who question what they are being told and those who accept it as fact. This level of divisiveness has crept into American society and doesn’t seem to be going anywhere soon. It will be interesting to see how we as a society can reawaken the minds of our people, and work towards a system where politicians are evaluated for the merits of their words, not how they are said.
Ultimately, people must decide whether or not they have been truly open to the information that is available to them. Many will choose to wallow in their ignorance because after all, it’s bliss, isn’t it? Ignorance is not new, and it is not going anywhere. However, it does not have to be the norm.
[Reply]
There is a funny youtube video that shows uninformed people, most of them black but that is not really important, and they are asked “What do you think of Obama’s vice president, Sarah Palin?” Their responses were comical. “Oh she is awesome! She will make a great leader!” and some responses similar to those. I find it quizzical that these people automatically proclaim she is great because she has the Obama label. I’m sure if you asked them “Who is Joe Biden?” they wouldn’t have an answer. A lot of “I dunno’s”.
People say that Fox news should be ashamed because they pre-meditated the questions. DUH that was the point. Nobody seems critical of CNN or CBS or NBC or ABC or almost every other media station that does the same thing to non-Obama supporters (like me). That’s ok. But when Fox News questions Obama, it’s the anti-Christ.
Obama’s policies are different, yes, but he has yet to prove anything. But that is not the topic. People throughout the country do not know Obama’s policies. They are under informed and support him for all the wrong reasons. They support him because he is black, which is fine, but that shouldn’t be the reason he gets votes, just like people shouldn’t vote for McCain because Obama is black. People need to look into his policies and make a decision based on that. Is his healthcare idea going to benefit you? Is his tax increase going to benefit you? Do you agree with his stance on the War on Terror? If yes, then vote for him, if no, then don’t. If you agree with some but not all, prioritize what you think is important and make a decision based on that, not because he is black or good looking or has a beautiful family, because McCain has a good family too and can stand on a stage and read a teleprompter also.
But, Obama is our president because the people spoke. We must support his decisions because we are Americans and we always have stood behind our country first. However, we cannot let him go unregulated. We must challenge him, not to defeat him, but to strengthen him. Challenge the healthcare bill, not because we don’t need it, but to point out scenarios that it needs improvement, or if it is even the best possible thing for our country’s health system. I do not agree with almost everything Obama stands for or is promoting. But am I going to undermine his presidency like so many people did to Bush? No. He is my president just as much as he is anyone else’s in this great country, so for now Obama is my homeboy just like he is yours.
[Reply]
First, let’s be clear about the real problem in this video: the book signing takes place in Ohio i.e. Ohio State fans. Enough said.
But seriously, in Sam’s update, he challenged us to relay how, as citizens and as people, this video makes us feel. Personally, I find it a bit scary. It doesn’t make me angry because I expect it. We live, not in a democratic society, but in a republic. I understand that the average person doesn’t feel a personal responsibility to understand political issues and that most will only seek to learn more about the issues that directly affect them. Many Americans live stressful and busy lives. They do not have the time to listen to, digest, analyze, and debate issues of importance. At the end of the day, most will rely on their elected officials to do this for them.
However, the fact remains that America’s ignorance is vast. This of course scares me. How could it not? And not only do many citizens not know our nation’s issues, but an increasing amount of people get their political information from late night television shows and comedy central entertainment like The Daily Show, The Colbert Report and Jay Leno. To me, this fact is equally as disheartening. Again, I can’t condemn it because I understand that for some people, these shows provide a break from the pressures and responsibilities that they face, and that is a great thing. But to actually take the content from these shows and use it as the sole information to form your beliefs is ridiculous. Again, it’s scary.
To summarize, understanding our nation’s issues can be overwhelming. Many don’t have the time, general knowledge, or inclination to really learn about the issues. The question then becomes, how can we change this? Lamenting the situation isn’t going to change the facts.
Americans are increasing cynical about the medias that they use. Perhaps this is why shows like The Daily Show are so popular; These programs are painfully one sided and make no attempt to hide their associations and opinions. When it comes to regular news stations such as CNN or Fox, people continuously question whether the information is conservative or liberal. Perhaps people’s awareness of issues will happen organically as the popularity of the Internet increases and people can be more selective in their media choices.
I also think some responsibility relies with the elected officials. They should not feel comfortable with their elected position if they know voters were ignorant or misinformed. Therefore in addition to their own platforms, why not promote general knowledge about issues? The goal for the politicians should not be to deceive the nation with words or advertisements but to be voted into office by a group of people that fully understand and support that politician’s goals and policies. Is this too much to ask—a Utopian view? Possibly. However, forward thinking is the only way to deal “national ignorance”, and that is the best I got for now..
[Reply]
I know that the update says about not knowing much about politics but I am just like everyone else. I do not know nearly enough about Obama’s ideas and policies. I am embarrassed about it too. I do not even know that much about the topics that matter to me, like animals rights. The only reason I did not like our past president George Bush is because my dad told me some facts on his treatment of animals, like how he let some rich business men he was trying to influence hunt endangered animals. I also know that he does not care about protecting the environment; he is more concerned with oil drilling and money. I always tried to tell myself that I knew enough to justify opposing him and to being a Democrat. Deep down though I know that this is not enough, I need to go home and do my own research to discover what I like and dislike about Obama’s policies. I need specific facts so I can make an educated decision. Despite knowing that I am ignorant when it comes to our president and our government I know that it will probably take me a long time to actually sit down and look at the facts.
I am a vegetarian and I have been for seven years. It is a huge part of my life, the rights of animals and the treatment of them in slaughter houses. Despite this it took me years and years to get the facts so that I could have an educated argument with the people around me. And still, even though I know all these facts on why its better to be a vegetarian: the unethical treatment of animals, the grain used to feed cattle that could be used to fight world hunger, even the pollution caused by all the transportation, I still rarely prove my point to my opponents. This is because no matter how much my facts make sense the ignorant meat eater always thinking they have a good point. What is infuriating is that these points are always misinformed! The meat eater spits out a dumb response because they know nothing about the topic and when I have no immediate response they believe I was proven wrong. This always leaves me fuming and the other person smug. Unfortunately, there are worse responses. A lot of my friends decide to choose ignorance. They say the do not want to know. They like the taste of meat too much. Not until I wrote this did I realize that that is who I am when it comes to politics. I choose to be ignorant because it is the easy route. Now that I have finished writing this I am going to go and look up Obama’s policies. Thank you for opening my eyes.
[Reply]
After watching that video it really showed how ignorant our country is when it comes to politics and political leaders. The President position used to be one that was based off of knowledge, experience, and a smart plan. Now it seems that our President is one that needs to have charisma and swagger; someone that can walk the red carpet better than they can create a healthcare plan. It is sad that so many people in our country claim to support certain candidates, yet have no reason as to why they back the person. A prime example of this was last year’s Presidential election. Obama was simply a charismatic figure that appealed to the youth and minorities in our country. He had minimal political experience, and had radical ideas of ending the war right away and lowering our taxes. A year after his election he seems to have done just the opposite. He recently decided to send an additional 30,000 troops to Afghanistan, and taxes are continuing to rise. Now it is not the voters’ fault that Obama hasn’t done the things he told voters he would. But the problem is that most of the voters don’t know or even care. With the recession hurting many US families, a lot of people are just happy to have food on their plates and a little money in their wallets. They don’t care about foreign policy. They don’t care about abortion. It is sad to see our country lose interest and focus on what is truly important. The decisions we make in terms of who gets elected into office and how long they stay in office carry an enormous amount of power and can very well change our entire country around. Yet nobody seems to care enough to pay attention to the viewpoints of a lot of candidates. I am not entirely innocent of this either. I will admit I need to find answers for myself. The problem is that channels like CNN and Fox News love to spoon feed everyone information and act as if their word is God’s word. People need to realize that the opinion held by a CNN newscaster should not be taken to the bank as fact. Rush Limbaugh cannot predict the future, so after listening to his radio show people should not come away thinking all Democrats are going to take over the world in the next 10 years. If people truly want to gain knowledge about today’s politics there are better ways to do so than listening to the rigid opinions of others. Listening to these shows is a great way to keep up to date with current events, but ultimately you need to come up with your own opinion, not pass on someone else’s and claim it as yours.
[Reply]
In the blog titled “Those Rusty Brains,” it mentions how people generally do not use their brains when they think or converse. Many people are disillusioned and think that they are using their brains, but if one truly listens or analyzes any of the conversations she hears during a day, it would not be hard to make an argument for the lack of brain activity that is taking place. It seems today that many people base their own opinions on the opinions of others or on what they have seen or heard on television, the radio, and the internet. People are not thinking critically or making their own opinions but rather spit out often misinterpreted and paraphrased opinions and statements they have heard from others. It would be interesting to see how many people could make a legitimate case for something as simple as why they belong to a particular political party. I would like to see a study that shows how many kids belong to the same political party as their parents or guardians. To me, it seems that part of the problem about the lack of critical thinking skills is a result of people not wanting to offend others. Some of the topics that would require the most analytical and critical thinking skills are typically deemed not appropriate to talk about in the social realm. These topics are typically reserved for classrooms and political debates and talk shows on the television and radio. How many times does the typical person hear in a lifetime to not talk about religion, gay marriage, politics, and abortion? It is a shame that people get so fired up and aggressive about these topics that they are not supposed to be talked about. It is situations like these that have forced the general person’s critical thinking skills to be placed on the back burner. Everyone has to resort to general mind-numbing topics such as the weather, sports, and little happenings. It is hard to use analytical and critical thinking abilities when one has to resort to talking about those mundane topics. Another reason this occurs is that people just generally are not interested in learning about topics that require those thinking skills, so then they do not have to use their brains. The majority of the population would rather focus on the status of Jon and Kate rather than the current state of the economy. It is a shame that is has come to this, but that is the truth. Without any genuine interest in topics that require thinking skills, it is hard to use them. Until people start to get involved and interested in the topics that really do matter and require thought, it is safe to assume that this sad state of underused brains will continue indefinitely
[Reply]
Now that you mention it, Sam, there really isn’t too much thinking in this day and age. There are many people out there that have grown up with certain beliefs and values that were beaten (in some cases literally) into their young minds. A lot of these people end up sticking to their guns, rather than looking over the fence to see what the other side is like. Who knows? Maybe you can get a completely different and even better view from the other side.
Sadly, there are people out there that feel a bit too comfortable where they are. This makes me mad, but I understand why this happens. We all have a comfort zone of sorts. They can be anything, really. Stepping out of what makes you feel secure or what you are so sure about is not the most comfortable thing in the world, hence why these are referred to as comfort zones. The problem with sticking to your guns is that you don’t allow yourself to grow. Getting different viewpoints on any matter allows you to get closer to the truth. You can find out whether what you knew was wrong or right, you can find out if what you had just heard from another source was wrong or right, or what you just heard from a source could lead you to a new way of thinking. The path towards the possible truth that you discovered by stepping out of your comfort zone is the growth that I was talking about. Even if it turns out that you were right from the get-go, you still walked the path; therefore, you have still grown, since you stepped out of your comfort zone.
When it comes to politics and religion, I notice that a lot of people tend to stick with their guns, and I will admit that I’m guilty of this. There are people that have grown up in an environment that is supportive of the republican party. That’s all fine and dandy, but there are people out when you completely ignore the other parties, then you are the scum of society. This is what you were talking about, right Sam? Too many people pick their sides too early without even hearing the other side of the story. The same story applies to those who are religious. There are many metric tons of religions in our world. The followers of these religions normally don’t consider any other religion to be ‘the right one’ but their own. Again, this goes back to the whole comfort zone thing I was talking about, earlier. All of this ignorance in the world is killing me!
Well, Sam, I hope this is what you were looking for as a response. I’m hoping that it’s at least a step in the right direction.
[Reply]
Well in today’s world of technology, internet, and fast news, people tend to go by what they hear on a regular basis. If you go around hearing the same thing all over the place, you are eventually going to start thinking is true. People are no longer take the time to do their own research to back up the things that believe to be true. The go with what they have heard and speak as if that’s all they need to know. Information is so easily available these days that people tend to assume that what they have heard is coming from a person that has researched what they are talking about, so they don’t take the time to do it themselves. An example of this is illustrated in the video posted on the blog. You can clearly see that the people interviewed at the Sarah Palin book signing, did not know what they were talking about. They went with what they believe she would do but when asked about her policies, they were not able to describe them. The interviewer even went as far as asking about the policies that the Obama administration has, and asked the crowd what they didn’t like about them. They were not able to detail them, but yet they were confident that they did not support them. How can these people back a candidate if they are unsure of what policies their candidate has or what changes they could make? I personally am not very politically active, I really don’t follow politics, however, whenever a topic interest or intrigues me I try to research the topic so that I would be able to discuss it with confidence if I ever was asked about it. I don’t like giving people information I don’t feel confident on. If I do give them information I am not too sure about, I make sure to say the phrase “I am not too sure about it” and that if they are interested on the subject that they should also research it themselves. Many people, as I said earlier, tend to go by what they hear, and if they hear the same thing over and over again they would assume it is true, without ever taking the time to do some research themselves. These kinds of people are exposed when they are asked questions about the topic that they seem to know much about and yet are unable to answer them. In a world where information is so easily available, asking questions to other individuals seems almost pointless. One could just as easily type the question on the internet and find the answer themselves. The people that do stay well informed and speak with confidence on their subject, the people that don’t just go by what they heard. The story goes gets shrunk down and changed as it is passed from person to person until it no longer resembles the original.
[Reply]
After reading Sam’s entry, “Those Rusty Brains” and watching the video, I was ashamed. In the land of the free and the home of the brave, if that video is a representation of what it means to be a proud American, I would like to relinquish my American Citizenship. I found it apalling that those individuals had the nerve of allowing someone to record a video, while making a fool out of themselves. What was also ridiculous was the fact that they continued to act as if they were educated Americans, but they continued to throw phrases such as “Healthy America” and “fairness and realness”. I don’t understand if this is the American pride or these conservatives do not know when to stop. I am all for backing your political beliefs and supporting a candidate, but before you pick a side, understand why you are picking that side.
Once again, I found that the video very funny and hypocritical. The woman in the red sweater states that if Sarah Palin is elected as President, she would bring better judgment to office. So are you telling me that a graduate of Columbia University and Harvard Law lacks the capability of good judgment? Being a minority, I recognize myself with the Democrat Party; however, I understand that I am conservative on issues of economics and free trade. In order to prevent igonorant mistakes, we must do our own research and decide for ourselves rather than allowing the media to continue pulling our strings.
After showing the video to my roomate, we came to a conclusion that the video was very anti-conservative and illustrated a small number of ignorant conservative Americans. Also we decided that we would probably get similar results if the video was reversed and we asked liberal Americans on Obama’s issues. However, I pointed out that if Democrats were asked on the streets they would more likely admit to their igonorance rather than continuing to act as if they are “educated” conservatives. In the video one man clearly stated that he did not know any of Sarah Palin’s stances; however, the majority of the other individuals who were also igonorant of Sarah Palin’s stances continued to act stubborn and act as if they were knowledgeable. My main argument with my roomate was that an igonorant Democrat would admit to it, but an ignorant Republican would rather look foolish trying act knowledgeable than admitting that they were ignorant.
The United States Presidential Election has transformed into a highschool popularity contest that depends on a candidate’s visual appeal rather than the individual’s stances on important issues. Prior to the 2008 election, I believed that our country had come a long way since the days of voting for a candidate because of his support for a race. However, we learned in the 2008 election that we re-entered the world of racial politics, as the color of Barack Obama’s skin played a crucial role in his election.
[Reply]
Fast Food News Media
I often wonder where our nation is headed if the information on the most pressing issues that all Americans are facing is preferably absorbed through the so called “fast food news” media. It is utterly appalling that even some Americans that are considered to be educated, that one would naturally accredit with the ability to question things and think for themselves, are on the front line of the fast food news media. For God’s sake, how would you explain the fact that even individuals with college degrees wait for political pundits to spit out their political views, obviously infused with their own opinions and biases, to catch upon what is going on in the political realm! No wonder the line separating the former republican vice president candidate Sarah Palin, and The comedian Tina Fey gets blurred at the point where no one can distinguish who said what and when! I am sure everyone remembers during the last US presidential election, Tina Fey, on Saturday Night Live, impersonating Sarah Palin, said that she would be an expert on foreign related policies because she can see Russia from her house! The famous line took life of its own at the point where most people thought that Sarah Palin actually made that statement.
Where people are we going as a nation if we cannot even understand or at least make an effort to learn about issues that the nation is facing. These political issues, such as health care bill that is being worked on by both house of representatives and the senate, international trade policies, Afghanistan war policy put forth by President Barack Obama… affect all of us on the daily basis. It is critical for all Americans to join their efforts and vote into political offices leaders who will steer this country into the direction dictated by all Americans. This goal can only be attained if everyone started thinking for themselves by reading different news articles from different sources especially from non main-stream media. That would allow Americans to synthesize their own opinions on the most important issues that our nation is dealing with. Democracy is shaped by the people; we are the ones who vote our leaders into their policy making offices. Is it not sad to realize that millions of people who voted in the last presidential election would not be able explain briefly what are the positions of their preferred candidate on the most important issues that our country is or was facing! How can we cast our votes without knowing the candidate’s agenda! This lazy and ridiculous mentality has to change if we want our country to make steps in positive direction. All Americans must be proactive in learning and understanding 21st century problems that we all have to solve. By all Americans, of course, I include Sarah Palin! If she ever wants to run for the Presidency office, she better be able to answer when she gets asked what she reads to learn and understand current issues.
Fast Food News Media
I often wonder where our nation is headed if the information on the most pressing issues that all Americans are facing is preferably absorbed through the so called “fast food news” media. It is utterly appalling that even some Americans that are considered to be educated, that one would naturally accredit with the ability to question things and think for themselves, are on the front line of the fast food news media. For God’s sake, how would you explain the fact that even individuals with college degrees wait for political pundits to spit out their political views, obviously infused with their own opinions and biases, to catch upon what is going on in the political realm! No wonder the line separating the former republican vice president candidate Sarah Palin, and The comedian Tina Fey gets blurred at the point where no one can distinguish who said what and when! I am sure everyone remembers during the last US presidential election, Tina Fey, on Saturday Night Live, impersonating Sarah Palin, said that she would be an expert on foreign related policies because she can see Russia from her house! The famous line took life of its own at the point where most people thought that Sarah Palin actually made that statement.
Where people are we going as a nation if we cannot even understand or at least make an effort to learn about issues that the nation is facing. These political issues, such as health care bill that is being worked on by both house of representatives and the senate, international trade policies, Afghanistan war policy put forth by President Barack Obama… affect all of us on the daily basis. It is critical for all Americans to join their efforts and vote into political offices leaders who will steer this country into the direction dictated by all Americans. This goal can only be attained if everyone started thinking for themselves by reading different news articles from different sources especially from non main-stream media. That would allow Americans to synthesize their own opinions on the most important issues that our nation is dealing with. Democracy is shaped by the people; we are the ones who vote our leaders into their policy making offices. Is it not sad to realize that millions of people who voted in the last presidential election would not be able explain briefly what are the positions of their preferred candidate on the most important issues that our country is or was facing! How can we cast our votes without knowing the candidate’s agenda! This lazy and ridiculous mentality has to change if we want our country to make steps in positive direction. All Americans must be proactive in learning and understanding 21st century problems that we all have to solve. By all Americans, of course, I include Sarah Palin! If she ever wants to run for the Presidency office, she better be able to answer when she gets asked what she reads to learn and understand current issues.
Fast Food News Media
I often wonder where our nation is headed if the information on the most pressing issues that all Americans are facing is preferably absorbed through the so called “fast food news” media. It is utterly appalling that even some Americans that are considered to be educated, that one would naturally accredit with the ability to question things and think for themselves, are on the front line of the fast food news media. For God’s sake, how would you explain the fact that even individuals with college degrees wait for political pundits to spit out their political views, obviously infused with their own opinions and biases, to catch upon what is going on in the political realm! No wonder the line separating the former republican vice president candidate Sarah Palin, and The comedian Tina Fey gets blurred at the point where no one can distinguish who said what and when! I am sure everyone remembers during the last US presidential election, Tina Fey, on Saturday Night Live, impersonating Sarah Palin, said that she would be an expert on foreign related policies because she can see Russia from her house! The famous line took life of its own at the point where most people thought that Sarah Palin actually made that statement.
Where people are we going as a nation if we cannot even understand or at least make an effort to learn about issues that the nation is facing. These political issues, such as health care bill that is being worked on by both house of representatives and the senate, international trade policies, Afghanistan war policy put forth by President Barack Obama… affect all of us on the daily basis. It is critical for all Americans to join their efforts and vote into political offices leaders who will steer this country into the direction dictated by all Americans. This goal can only be attained if everyone started thinking for themselves by reading different news articles from different sources especially from non main-stream media. That would allow Americans to synthesize their own opinions on the most important issues that our nation is dealing with. Democracy is shaped by the people; we are the ones who vote our leaders into their policy making offices. Is it not sad to realize that millions of people who voted in the last presidential election would not be able explain briefly what are the positions of their preferred candidate on the most important issues that our country is or was facing! How can we cast our votes without knowing the candidate’s agenda! This lazy and ridiculous mentality has to change if we want our country to make steps in positive direction. All Americans must be proactive in learning and understanding 21st century problems that we all have to solve. By all Americans, of course, I include Sarah Palin! If she ever wants to run for the Presidency office, she better be able to answer when she gets asked what she reads to learn and understand current issues.
[Reply]
Rusty brains is a perfect way of describing how most Americans think these days. I’m sure were all guilty of doing it in some fashion but the fact that some people simply refuse to use their own minds and fashion their own opinions says a lot about that person. I personally hate when people get into arguments, whether with myself or someone around me, and everything they say is based off of what some talk show host, or news show host said. They have no ability to actually research and develop their own ideas. Personally I think most of these nightly news shows are all crap. Depending upon which channel you watch no matter who the host is they take one side and stick to that and try to force their opinions on you. However most Americans are probably willing to sit back and believe every word that these hosts spit out. They figure they must be knowledgeable and know exactly what they are talking about just because they have their own TV show. I understand that even reading material is not always true. Most newspapers put what they think will catch the attention of the readers whether it be completely true or not. I see this as an insult to us as Americans. We deserve to know exactly what is going on in our country at all times. I don’t want to hear what you think I want to hear. I want to hear the truth whether it be good or bad. I feel that today everything is about ratings not the people. If a TV show or a newspaper can make more money by publishing some crazy article or story with little accuracy to it rather than posting the true story simply to get viewers attention, they would absolutely do it. I like how Sam brings up the point of questioning things. If today all we are feed is what other people think and we ourselves have no possible way of collecting all the true data that is out there, the only real way we can find things out is to question everything. Ask questions like Sam said. We shouldn’t settle for someone else’s opinion. We should do what we can to collect every piece of information possible and use these pieces to form our own intelligent opinions. It really isn’t that hard of a concept to accept but for some reason it doesn’t happen. I think maybe it doesn’t happen because it goes along with the idea of Americans being lazy and expecting to be given everything. It doesn’t always work that way and if people could notice that sooner we could be a lot better off as a country in more ways than one.
[Reply]
When I was searching the race relations blog earlier today searching for a journal topic I stumbled on the post entitled “Those Rusty Brains” and I began to read it. As I read though the post I began to realise that it brought up a very clear problem in America. It showed us what many of us refuse to admit and that is as a country we are largely a very uninformed people when it comes to voting. A lot of the time what happens in these situations is that people simply vote based on a candidate’s particular party or by the way the candidate is portrayed in the media. I believe the ladder has happened in this situation. In the media particularly in the right based media such as Rush Limbaugh and on FOX news Sarah Palin has been brought to the forefront of the Republican Parties attempt to regain some ground in the battle for political dominance. The media has attempted to portray her as a smart, strong, and, decisive woman that people can count on to run their country. This is precisely where these people began to like Palin. The media often does no discuss a candidate’s issues rather they focus on personal attributes as is evident in this case. It appears that these people at the book signing really voted for Palin based on these factors and not on her issues. This is clearly evident in their response to the interviewers questions. We need a serious change in this country. We need to become more educated in the area of politics. What these people are doing is wrong and quite simply appalling. There is absolutely nothing wrong with supporting Sarah Palin but it should be done for the right reasons. I’m not saying that there is anything wrong with saying a candidate has strong leadership qualities but they are only useful when used to carry out promises on key issues. These people need to learn the issues that Sarah supports such as outlawing abortion, drilling for oil, and not nationalizing health care and vote for her based on these issues on top of her positive personal attributes. The freedom to vote is one of the most beautiful things about being an American citizen. It is sad that so many people take it for granted and misuse it or don’t even exercise it at all. There are countries in the world were people are forced to vote for things that they don’t want to under the threat of death. It doesn’t take much to be an informed voter either just a little time to take a look at some issues and it can make a huge difference.
[Reply]
It happened that in the last recitation something like this came up. We were all asking closing questions and someone asked, “Should there be a test to be able to vote to ensure that voters are making an informed decision?” I think that it wouldn’t be a terrible idea, in fact I think it might be a great idea. If the majority of the people voting were at least marginally informed, and understood what each candidate stood for they could more accurately choose the candidate that they really agreed with. It seems like a significant portion of people today vote straight down party lines, and/or are either uninformed or misinformed in general. I don’t want to say that they don’t have the right to vote, but I feel like they are a determent to the system if they vote on a whim. Diluting the vote could easily take an election one way or another, as we saw a few years ago in Florida. It would also help if everyone would use logic to make their decisions, but some people will be swayed by the candidates gender, or their race, or their religion. I can’t stand when people vote based on religion. I suppose it’s not fair to say that though. If someone really believes in something and it tells them to choose one way or the other, who am I to stop them. I just think that it’s a senseless way to vote.
I think that putting this test forth wouldn’t necessarily affect either party more than the other. Actually, I think that it could very well affect the parties. I mean that I think each party would have about the same amount of people fail this test. The video in this blog entry is completely one sided, but that was to be expected by the title. I doubt you would find many democrats at Sarah Palin’s book signing. I think that there is a bit of a difference between the misinformed in the parties though. I feel like more of the misinformed that favor the right wing are middle aged or older. I can’t think that many young people that I know that support the republicans, and those few that do are generally well informed. What I mean is that I think that generalizations about either party play at least a small role in most of young people’s decisions. Basically I think that being a democrat is often confused with being liberal, and I’m just saying they’re not the same thing even though they are often grouped together. For whatever reason I think they do get mashed together in to one in the minds of most young people, and to them it appears much more hip and cool than the republican party. Without thinking young people lean left, and as you get older something must change or the parties swap ideas but not names or something, but for whatever reason older people seem to be more right leaning if they’re uninformed. The minority in each group I think is more educated about their party, because it’s not necessarily the easy socially acceptable choice. I could be wrong about all of this though. I could just see the world that I live in, which is flooded with privileged young people. This probably isn’t a good snap shot of the real world.
[Reply]
2009 the age of reason and enlightenment. Well not actually. When a person that exhibit’s the sheer ignorance of Sarah Palin can be within a heart beat of the vice presidency and George Bush can be elected not once but twice, we are truly living in a society that has had its brain eroded by constant electronic stimulation and the twenty four hour news cycle of misinformation. And the sad thing is, it is only going to get worse as time marches on. Children being born today will look to electronic sources for truth and comfort and only find fear mongering and misinformation. Truth is rather difficult to find and its starting to become ever more difficult to find. When only a hand full of corporations control the vast majority of media, these corporations only let you know what they want you to know. As the blog post claims we are asked not to reason but to just go with the flow and accept what is presented by the media, until our brains become rusty and dilapidated. Also we are told by the media to pick a side of the political debate in such a way that if we even hear the views of the other side we should become violently ill and angry that someone would have the temerity to have different views. We need to stop and think about all sides of issues instead of falsely thinking that we have all the answers to every problem and that the other side is completely wrong. We need to reason through problems instead of just standing behind the dogma of party lines. People have certainly lost their curiosity with the world and are just too lazy to really dig deep to expand their minds and really attempt to find out how the world works. Perhaps if our brains are rusty for too long we as a society will completely lose the capacity to reason and innovate and we as a people will go through a process of devolving. Not to the level of primitive man but to the point that we will no longer be able to appreciate thing such things as a good debate or a fine piece of cinema unless its been sanitized by our corporate masters.
The conversation is dead, I’m not sure who killed it but it is certainly dead. We have no meaningful conversations, debate and or relationships anymore. The conversations were so inane and useless during the Thanksgiving holiday at my home that I wanted to drill a hole in my rusty brain. The whole conversation was based around the useless crap that my family was going to buy on black Friday and the difference between a tivo and a dvr. No thinking required to take a seat at my families table, and the sad thing is my mother has a masters degree.
Palin is a monster, but we the people created this monster. We created the monster by being complacent and not urging the media to ask politicians tough questions and helping to elect officials that aren’t even qualified to run a Dairy Queen, let alone this country.
[Reply]
Wow haha, I am not one to say I know everything, but if I support a candidate and go to their book signing, I would hope I have some knowledge of their policies. I believe people do not put enough thought into why they like a candidate or in what they believe in. I think many people are ignorant because they do not branch out of their comfort zone or try to understand others’ views. In this sense you can see in the video, that when a guy was asked where he gets his sources from, he says, “Fox news”, and this is only one source of news that’s a huge left news station, you cannot be surprised to hear his ignorant ideas. Also to say that only Sarah Palin’s supporters are ignorant is ignorance in itself. There are just as many Obama supporters that are just as ignorant if not more. I am not saying one side has more or less, but just like Sam says, I would hope Americans have more thought to their ideas then just cause. I would hope Americans have reasons, justifications for their ideology and why they think or came to a certain conclusion. I think people do not try to think deeply about the issues that most concern them, they hear something that correlates to their reasoning and thought and think they are right, and by doing so they do not ask questions. This video was very well articulated and it said more than just about Sarah Palin’s supporters, it spoke volumes about America as a whole and its people. I am saddened to see how we are portrayed through these interviews and take shots at one another oppose to trying to educate one another. I wish we all better understood politics and understood the importance of it throughout our country, let alone the world. Politics is very important and deals with our daily lives and affects us both directly and indirectly. Personally I was shocked seeing such responses in this video, but these types of voters are on both sides and ignorance does not stop our elections, it only maybe lessens their meaning. I wish that one day there would be a law or standard for those that vote for their candidate, like maybe know one or two things about their politics then just their name, race, and religion. I know that might be impossible to do and would take away one of our biggest freedoms, but I feel like allowing ignorance to be a part of our election is even sadder. When people realize knowledge is power and how much knowledge and power could go a long away, which alone may bring America back to its place in the world. If we could go one step further in the voting process and have some requirement in order for people to vote, I think it will go a long ways. Americans need a better understanding of their very own politics, to even begin to understand others!
[Reply]
Unfortunately, this affects everyone, from students to people working full-time. We consider the things that used to be expected of everyone now to be extraordinary. It’s interesting to see how children are raised now to jump through the hoops, as we discussed in class. They want to do the bare minimum, because we all learn that Cs earn degrees. It is not common to see children raised to be extraordinary. They don’t get taught to question things like they did in more revolutionary times. We are way past the times of protests conducted by the youth of this nation. My mother participated in a sit-in at her high school so the females would be allowed to wear jeans to school. I feel like that says a lot about the times of the late ‘60s or early ‘70s. Something that seems small like whether female students could wear jeans versus being required to wear skirts to school every day was protested by a large group of students. This event was significant enough to get the administration of the school to change the policy. I know that such an event would not be as common now. I recall in my high school, the female students being against certain dress codes but rather than taking initiative to do something about it, they would just complain about it to those around them and break the rules anyway.
Now I may not know a lot about political issues, but it does not mean that I’m completely ignorant of the world around me. When I have the opportunity I do my fair share of reading, but I get frustrated when I hear things about current political issues. I like to read about history and make connections to what I do know about current issues. However, I took this class because I have a strong interest in social issues and a bit of an obsession with race and its connections to other topics.
As a member of the hip hop community, we are always listening to different artists and exploring dance moves, clothing, and lyrics to see how all these things connect with how they change. We discuss all the different racial and gender barriers to the community.
However it’s also interesting to me to push the limits and be somewhat of a sociopath and ask those difficult questions, because I would really like to know the answers. Though sometimes we all have those sophomoric conversations about our favorite beer or who has the cutest shoes, just recently we caught ourselves in a conversation questioning our guy friends about certain sexual acts they were bragging about and how it degrades females. We turned something shallow and maybe common for college students to discuss into something more, because life will be a much more fulfilling experience if you surround yourself with people who will have those discussions with you.
[Reply]
I’ll willingly admit that I don’t know jack about the current state of affairs in our country’s political arena both at home and abroad. This isn’t because I’m lazy or have no care to keep up with current events, it’s just that today’s media isn’t journalism. They don’t report facts. I can watch 3 different reports on 3 different news networks about the same topic and come away thinking 3 to 6 different ways about whatever the reports were discussing.
Back in summer of 2008 I watched CNN almost every day during my lunch break (trying to keep up with issues during the presidential election, helping to decide for whom I’d vote) at my full time job. That’s about thirty or forty minutes of news watching every day, and I’d (admittedly without any qualitative data to back me up) estimate that that’s just about average for national news watchers. That summer made me lose all faith in national news networks. With the way that they present issues to people, layer after layer of spin (love the editorial comments sprinkled throughout almost every report) it’s no wonder that nobody out there understands these issues. Unless you’re sitting around watching C-Span and seeing the actual debates in government how are you supposed to really grasp what’s going on out there.
Mass media has warped the political process to such a degree that it’s probably barely reminiscent of what the people who started this country intended. You can’t find facts on TV or in the paper any more. Every story is written like a work of fiction. There’s an introduction that presents you with the basic background facts to set you up for the rest of the report. Then there’s a climactic point that the author makes about his topic, and then a conclusion designed to make you think whatever the writer intended you to think after you read/hear it. I notice it all the time.
When Plaxico Burress was going through his legal tribulations last year I heard an ESPN anchor say that they agreed with his attorney, if it hadn’t been a famous football player up for such charges, he would’ve gotten off without serving any jail time. I disagree with that statement strongly. How many young kids in New York or any area where gun control is an issue would have gotten the same or worse punishment? Discharging a firearm in a public place is a pretty serious thing to do. Anyway, I digress. My point is that I was talking with my uncle several days after hearing this report on ESPN, and he said that if it had been him or me on the stand we would’ve gotten off without issue. It’s fine if he draws this conclusion, but the way he said it was almost word-for-word identical to the ESPN report that I’d been listening to a few days before. Before I stopped watching the news I’d hear it all the time.
People in that video are complaining about the loss of their freedom, and things like communism (the war’s over people) and propaganda (never mind the fact that a lot of the freedoms they’d probably complain about were taken away by a previous conservative candidate). They don’t even seem to understand that they’re victims to propaganda on a daily basis (or at least whenever they watch Fox News, MSNBC, CNN, or any commercial news station). Mass media is our biggest window to the world (although it’s starting to lose out to another major player in world events). The people who control mass media understand this and they’re willing to put whatever color glass into that window that they think suits it.
I think the best way to deal with this is to step around the “official” media and give an unedited voice to the people. One of the best ways of doing this is through blogging. The scientists of the world have graciously bestowed us with the greatest technological invention since either electricity or the combustion engine, and it’s being put to use on a greater and greater scope every day. Blogging allows us to highlight important issues, make an argument, inspire other people throughout the world to say what they think, and spark critical debate about issues that people can then carry over into their every day lives (this hopefully sparks critical conversation at family/community events, or at the Thanksgiving table as Sam always references in class with such amusement).
I really hope this entry doesn’t sound too long-winded. It’s just that while I understand that we’re always going to be victims of control in certain ways, we don’t need to be victims of control in EVERY way; blindly following Fox News or CNN isn’t going to make you smarter or more knowledgeable. It’s just a way that they get you to pick a team so you can wave your fist and shout along without fully understanding why you’re even there. Just remember to check a few things before doing that: remember where you heard it, remember why you care, and then be able to explain it to someone should they ask you why you’re waving your fist in the air.
[Reply]
I do agree that one of our major problems in 2009 is indeed the fact that people today don’t think the way we should. Personally, I believe that technology is responsible for many people to be lazy today. Sure many technologies make people lazy, but when you think about it, people even take laziness as far as to not be able to form an opinion for themselves. A lot of times, people will just believe whatever they hear and people are shallow minded to believe one thing a person says and takes it as actual fact. They never try to do the research themselves, until they are later proven wrong.
When Sam talks about “Fast food news”, I assume that he is talking about how quick people are to believe what they hear. Headlines also contribute to a lot of the fast food news because people unfortunately take the headline in without reading the article. Most people that browse the internet don’t take the time to read it and just skim the first paragraph, assuming that’s what the headline is about. We must be smarter and take the opportunity to earn as much knowledge as we can, thus making reading the article beneficial. If we read it, we would be able to have something to talk about to others and we could even help form our own opinions and views.
Obama is a good example of this issue, because most people know who Obama is, but don’t know Obama well. Even many of those that voted for Obama don’t truly know what Obama is about. I am sure that most people that voted for Obama voted for him because he is Black. If you had to ask most people about Obama’s policies or any specific question regarding the president, most people would give you a one word answer or a half-assed response. Why? Because they only base their views on Obama on what they hear or they didn’t take the time out to do their own research and educate themselves. It is laziness, but naturally most people just accept it and don’t do anything about it.
One thing I like about this post is that it caused many people, including myself to always keep an open mind. Critical thinking is very important and its one of those things that help make us well rounded people. This has taught me that its important to use my brain and that its good to have an open outlook on the world, because most people only know their country and their customs. Most of these people have never made an attempt to understand or try to become part of another culture. The internet is only a start and a small step bringing people around the world together. From there we must continue our journey and put ourselves out there.
[Reply]
It is extremely saddening to the citizens who still keep up with what is going on in the political and legislative world to see that other citizens who are completely negligent about what the true issues are and for what candidates are actually standing have an equal say in who controls and influences our country. It is distressing to realize that the majority of the people in this world have fallen victim to not thinking. Last year when it was time to decide for whom we were going to vote, many of the people to whom I talked did not really know where Barack Obama and John McCain stood on the issues. My own roommate thought that she would vote one way, but after I convinced her to do some research, she realized that she sided more with the opposite way than she had thought. Our generation is stereotyped as being a more liberal generation, so this idea is placed in our minds and I believe that a majority of the population voted for Barack Obama simply because everyone else believed that this was the best way for America, and when so many people think one way, they all can’t be wrong, right? (Sounds familiar . . . Nazi Germany anyone?)
And actually, where did this interviewer find these people? It seems like they went to the most ill informed town in the nation. I cannot honestly believe that so much of the nation is this way. Sure, we have a large group of citizens who do not follow politics, but there must be people out there they could have interviewed who did have some concept of what was going on or for what Sarah Palin actually stands. I think that this video, while somewhat accurate, is also staged to make it look so much worse than it really is.
Like you said, this lack of thinking is something that can easily be witnessed just by walking around this campus and listening to the conversations that people are having. There is little substance to their conversations; just the usual everyday chatter that people use to fill the time. Very seldom do I ever overhear a conversation that will delve into a deeper level. Personally, I am upset by the shallow discussions that I am forced to uphold because no one wants to be involved in an awkward setting where they actually have to share their feelings and put some reasoning behind those thoughts.
So are we destined to live in a world where everyone else repeats the same pointless conversations day after day? Or should we do something about this, and if so, what? I do not think that we should let people get away with the simple answers. We should demand deeper answers from them. Force them to use their brains and think. Only then will our conversations be worth anything.
[Reply]
I’ll be the first to say I have a “rusty” brain when dealing with politics. It’s all so shady and blurry that hearing different things from different people it makes it hard to ever know what’s really going on so I don’t like to speak my opinion or support things im not educated enough in. I didn’t want to vote not knowing all the facts and not having a strong feeling of support, since it’s the election of the president I didn’t feel justified voting not being fully educated. That being said seeing other clearly un educated people preaching obama’s “change” and buying into trendy appeal from celebrities it almost made me not want to vote knowing they were just doing it because everyone in college has to show our “knowledge”. I just can’t believe people waiting for a book signing for Sarah Palin’s new book couldn’t even answer in the slightest what she supports. If im going to read a book on someone and support them enough to go to their book signing then im going to defiantly know what their views and ideals are. The people were not only speechless for many of the questions but some even thought they knew what they were talking about and continued by bullshitting incorrectly about things they clearly don’t know. I feel like this uneducated bullshitting happens all the time around us and is increasingly more widespread. I’m pretty sporadic and enjoy the randomness the world around us holds but some people won’t even put out the effort in trying to have a creative random conversation. Maybe it’s because people are content enough with “talking” to people through phones and computers from texting to facebook but how socially stimulating is that? People are content enough with what they know and don’t need to establish with others so communicating is easy enough through technology. Communication alone is bad but it’s only getting worse seeing little five year olds getting cell phones, for what? I know in our generation video games and technology were up and coming but by the time it really exploded we had already experienced the creative mind expanding days playing outside and playing with actual toys having to socialize with other children now a days children are brought up surrounded by high tech video games and computers, you don’t even have to go out to go bowling anymore you can play it by yourself in front of your home television. It’s even bad that playing a multi player video game has turned into microphone headsets talking to each other. This social dysfunction is turning peoples mind to mush and crushing our social society.
[Reply]
In regards to how I feel about being ignorant about basic social and political issues, I would say that is a tough question that can be answered in many ways. I feel as though I do need to know more about the basic issues but it is a topic that does not really catch my interest, as is the case with many other people. When something does not interest me, I tend to tune it out and not pay attention to it and this is something that I would like to change. I have never been interested in politics growing up but now that I am getting older I feel as though it is a necessity that I get informed so that I am aware of what is going on in the world. When I read the paragraphs leading into the discussion, it talked about exercising your brain and thinking deeper into certain things and this reminded of me of my cousin who is into philosophy and is always thinking deep and questioning things. Listening to him and reading this article gets you to realize that you have to apply this to life and you have to question things more so that you will be better informed.
Watching the video, I found it hilarious that so many people were uneducated about the different policies. I know that if I were interviewed and asked these same questions I would have the same exact response. Many people may think that the older generation would be more educated than the younger generation just because they are older. This is not the case however because there were a good amount of middle aged to older people that were interviewed in the video and they had no idea Sara Palin’s policies were even thought they claimed to be full supporters of her. Like a few people commented previously, many people were just going with the crowd in this election and they were just jumping on the bandwagon of what many other people were doing. I think that it is a good thing that we actually got people to go out and vote last year, especially the younger generation. I think that the next thing we need to do is to get people informed on the social and political issues as well as the different policies. It may seem impossible but I feel as though if it was possible to get that many people to come out and vote last year, then just about anything can be achieved with hard work. How would we get people more informed? That is a question that would require a lot of thought in order to figure out a solution.
[Reply]
I also agree that people do not talk about situations like they are suppose to.
I also believe that these days people as a whole do not talk about situations
thoroughly. I feel that we do not speak about how we truly feel about topics that affect our lives. We just go with flow and express how we feel about situations. Maybe certain
situations we should just go all out and really talk about how we feel but in
reality, its not that simple.
Now, lets talk about the real stuff, let us be real. People talk a lot of SHIT!! And I am not saying that at times I do not talk things that do not really know about but it is kind of ridiculous. I feel as though people as a whole do not investigate and try to find out what topics actually mean. For instance when they were talking about Sarah Palin and her running for the presidency a lot of people did not know what they were talking about. It amazes me how much crap we talk. And where do we get our information from? Why cant we explain the reasons why we feel the way that we do? Its amazing that we take what other people say and run thousands of miles with it. Maybe its our way of conforming to something that we are suppose to believe in.
For instance, a lot of people that were talking about Sarah Palin and her representation of what “America” is suppose to be is a whole lot of crap. I didn’t know that America is suppose to be conservative, I thought America is suppose to be the land of opportunity were everyone is expected to keep their culture but openly live in a new one. They did not know what were the policies that she stood for. They did not know what she said she would change or if she said she would change anything. What cracked me up was the one guy who spoke about the two books that President Obama wrote but did not have one clue about what the book was about. AMAZING!!!
I am not trying to be judgmental because in actuality, in some instances I do the same thing. And probably many people in the world do the same, in which they discuss not what they know but what they were told. I think about many stereotypes that I believe just because I heard someone say it. And believe it or not, people sometimes believe things just because they train themselves to. I am happy that I took the time out to do this particular blog because it forces me to try and find out how I feel about things rather than believing what others want me to.
[Reply]
So I could easily make fun of all these clueless people, but it’s really not even fair because I couldn’t hold an informed side of a debate for any those topics. Even still..did that woman really say “not just drill for oil but drill for gas?” This brings me to Sam’s question. How does it feel be totally ignorant of basic social and political issues? Well, it doesn’t make me happy with myself. Part of the problem with that video with those people is that they want to sound smart. They might not really even believe the things they’ve said, but they’d rather make it seem like they know what’s going on than admit they don’t know anything. Thankfully, I’ve never been interviewed on camera about politics or anything I was clueless about. But I would still prefer to be able to contribute an intelligent statement if I were to have a political discussion at any time.
I don’t like the feeling of ignorance at all. Accessing news has never been easier, but I usually just don’t read up on these things. When I think about this ignorance, it reminds me of the puppet string idea. I believe things people say or what I hear without having any knowledge of it myself. I think I’m letting myself be manipulated, and I don’t ever think about the information presented by the media and people on television. So I would call this the “rusty brain” part. But I get the vague impression that some of these issues don’t apply to me, even if they do. I think my concern will increase when I actually become a real grown-up and start doing my own taxes and trying to get back on health insurance.
So I feel ignorant. But I’m not stupid. I have the capacity to at least semi-understand the basics of the issues. I’ll never stop asking big questions about the world. And I don’t take in all information like a robot and assume it’s true. Though believing a story when it’s false probably happens to me more than I know. What’s the percentage of Americans with that level of ignorance, anyway? I would guess a lot. Most people are probably like that. It’s a problem.
I would say we need improvements in our education system if we want this to improve. I’m in my last year of college, and I still don’t know a lot of things. Obviously learning never ends. So we have to get through to the adults not in school..through television maybe? Better educational programming? Americans watch a lot of tv, so how about getting Fox news cancelled; that might be a good start. I’m not sure how much I’m ever going to fix my own ignorance, or how to solve this issue of ignorant people like those in the video. But I hate the idea of being a puppet. I want more control, and I know I don’t want to be so easily manipulated.
[Reply]
“Stop the spending… All of it.”
“Drill baby, drill!”
“Suppose we drill for oil. And not just for oil, but for gas.”
“Well, I watch FOX news a lot.”
“We need people like her to speak up for reality.”
I think that if we knew what area of the country this was it would shed some light on the issue of where the rusty brains most likely come from. But in my opinion I think that more than two thirds of Americans would give similar answers if they were posed similar questions. I think that the quote, “well, I watch FOX News a lot,” epitomizes our middle-American conservatives. That’s exactly the product of our “drive-thru news” channels these days. It’s not responsible or healthy to listen to only one side of the political spectrum on issues or policies. You can’t have opinions based on one perspective, and we’ve seen what that does when people ask you to explain yourself. I liken it to static stretching; just sitting there and trying to touch your toes isn’t going to help you prevent injuries or improve your flexibility, whereas if you warm-up and prepare your muscles for the stretch you’ll accomplish both.
I’m not versed on foreign policy, or the war in Iraq, or taxes, or government spending. So I don’t talk about those issues. But honestly, I’m okay with being glib for now because I don’t feel the impact of those issues. I also am insensitive to potential criticism that might come my way because I don’t expect to put myself in a situation where I don’t have something to add to the conversation. Granted these people feel strong about their support for Palin, but their support doesn’t come from a desire to have the best possible person take the helm of our nation, rather it comes from the “feelings” they get from her. These people are “feelers,” not “thinkers.” They may listen to the right wing bias to “educate” themselves on issues, but its more to reaffirm their beliefs than anything. Politicians know this, and that is why they kiss babies, and the reason they go to small towns in America; to appeal to the feelers. Their stance on politics isn’t going to win them those votes, but rather what they say in “between the lines.”
To Sam’s suggestion to take ownership and describe what it’s like to be ignorant, honestly, I don’t do a lot of “feeling” on issues, I’m a thinker; I have to have facts. I think that’s how many people who take pride in their education approach this issue of ignorance. I understand that I can’t be versed in everything, and I don’t want to be. I’d much rather engage in discussions about European soccer or finance or girls. So ultimately, to answer the question; It rarely enters my conscience. And I’m not judging these people on their knowledge, or lack there of, but their thought process is suspect. This way of thinking about politics permeates much of America and because these people rarely “stretch” or “flex” their brains (because who are they going to talk to?), these “opinions” reciprocate and thus get acceptance amongst their surroundings. It’s a cycle. A cycle that I’m proud I don’t participate in.
[Reply]
It is amazing how people think they know things, but when asked valid questions that scratch beneath the surface of ‘general knowledge’ (I hesitate to use ‘common sense’ because a. it’s not common, and b. it requires people to think, which as this shows, few people do.)
The video where Sarah Palin could not name a newspaper comes to mind here. She couldn’t just throw the name of a paper out there? Really? I am such a cynic when it comes to politics- to the point where I’ll be honest- I did follow the election, and in the end voted for Obama simply because he’s black (I’m white if that makes a difference to how you read this) and because I thought that the psychological impact having a black president of the United States would be beneficial. (Even if it is not felt for generations). The ugly truth is that in Congress, party alliances and infighting makes the legislative process so inefficient…add in the power of the lobbies and logrolling…it becomes slightly ridiculous. And of course, how could I forget? The desire/pressure to be reelected is so enormous that it overwhelms all political decisions. So, as we are seeing, even if a candidate promises something on the campaign trail, the chances of him pursuing it, and (if he does) it passing through Congress are so small it’s almost laughable, if it weren’t so sad.
Out of all the possible candidates from the very beginning of the democratic primaries, if I could have voted for president then, I would have voted for Dennis Kucinich because he has a record of actual reform, a stance of environmental protection that he has stuck to for awhile, and was the only candidate standing for full rights for same-sex couples. The reason that he was left out (it was left out, not dropped out) was because he was purposefully excluded from a debate by the major media corporations. Fox, CNN, NBC and ABC did not allow him into the hall where the live debate was going on. The awful lack of integrity that the media has is disgusting. We hear about the ‘balloon kid’ for days, but actual news (how many soldiers are killed overseas today, what the president decided, what legislation Congress is discussing….) is not mentioned. Murders and rapes make the national news- regrettable incidents to be sure, but do we need to know that? Fuck no! honestly, if you were raped, the last thing that you’d want is it plastered all over the news. Really. And if your argument for it is that the more people know that it happens, the more people will be safe/reach out to get help; well, there are other ways to get that point across.
I disagree with the comment that the lack of intelligence isn’t the problem. It is my opinion that the shitty state of the American education system is exactly the problem with (almost) EVERYTHING. If, instead of the watered down version of American history that we get over and over and over again, we were taught the complex reality of life, given a broad picture with its many complications so that people were aware of the gaping holes in their knowledge, and could fill them in…there would be less people who sounded like this when they try to sound intelligent.
[Reply]
I am really happy Sam posted a blog about this, because I think about it and am reminded of it daily. Stupid people are everywhere. Some of them were not always stupid, except I guess when they were babies, yet they have found it very suitable. Somewhere throughout their lives they might have figured out they could get pretty far in this world by doing the bare minimum or simply not trying to expand their perspective, while other are too stupid to even think of that. My point is stupid people are everywhere, including positions of authority and power. Take Sarah Palin for example. She may not be the dumbest, although I think she is, yet she still managed to acquire a position of power and was even a potential vice president. How could someone manage to succeed so much in life, in terms of the typical standards, even though they clearly are not the sharpest tool in the shed. My point is we are all a product of our environment, and our environment allows us to be stupid and yet still successful in our lives. I honestly feel that this applies to way too many people, including those who hold positions in our government and on TV. I’m not saying these people aren’t or weren’t smart, I’m just saying they do not have to be, at least not in our modern world today.
Surprisingly enough, TV shows like the Daily show are what really brought this to my attention. It consistently points out just how dumb some of the people who the general public listen to really are. Like some of the news anchors on CNN or Fox News. Who make absurd and inappropriate comments on a daily basis, yet remain successful and are watched daily by thousands of people. A great example in my Opinion would be Nancy Grace. This lady could honestly be called one of the dumbest, yet in reality she is very well educated. If you watch her on TV you wouldn’t think she could have passed the third grade, for instance she didn’t know what a CZAR was. Yet in real life she’s college educated and even spent time studying in Oxford. I think it’s safe to say she has taken it to the next level, pretending to be dumb in order to be successful.
Take a good look at the way our language has progressed throughout the history of our country. We used to have such passion and make use of a huge vocabulary, yet we have only dumbed it down in the past hundred years.
Another example, George W. Bush, I rest my case.
[Reply]
lauriemulvey Reply:
December 16th, 2009 at 4:08 am
Going Without Brains
[Reply]
I have heard this issue for a few years now. Its ridiculous. I was actually asked by a black person "what you racist or something" because I was wearing a Mccain/Palin shirt. The term rusty brain does not come to mind. The term brainwashed comes to mind. Walking around campus last year during the election actually pissed me off, and I had to stop myself from flipping the fuck out. I think anyone, who is hounded to change there voting precinct then, after I agree am again hounded to register as a Democrat and to vote for Obama (which is completely and utterly illegal), and then on voting day when EVERY student at the HUB had an Obama shirt, and gave out Obama pins (which is completely and utterly illegal), and then after everything being called racist because I wore a Mccain shirt would piss anyone off. I just think its ridiculous how taboo it is to be a raging liberal on campus even though you cannot answer one political question. Granted Palin made some mistakes, but I am so damn happy that she is doing well. She shit on the shoes of every leftist media outlet who ripped her book apart and said how terrible it was, and how it is going to tank, when she sold OVER 1,000,000,000 copies and is on pace to make over 4 million. And Mr. false reporting himself Al Gores book of global warming babble sold less than 40,000. Thank you Sarah for strutting you stuff and doing your thing. People say "well she is just a super star, she is just a celebrity." Come on people. You think Mr. Obama was not a superstar? He was the most popular man in the world, and still probably is. And on a closing note, Mr. Obama just sent a shit ton more troops to Afghanistan and has not pulled out our troops, as well has completed almost none of his promises that he said he would (including ruling from the center, not the extreme left like he is). If George Bush would have done the shit that he has done after being in office for like a year he would have been slain. He would have been bashed and destroyed on every media show, every newspaper, and every late night show. Look at the facts, and do not continue to be a brainwashed leftist college student. Thanks.
-Al Gore
[Reply]
Just testing out the site…
[Reply]
This excerpt deals with the rational ignorance of voters. Information is too costly so it is very difficult for voters to look into every spectrum of the political elections. If voters were to look into every issue and every stance by politicians then they would be wasting much of their time. This rusty thinking leads to shortsightedness by voters. However these voters are extremely ignorant and view Sarah Palin as an idol and a symbol rather than looking into her viewpoints. The people in the video say that Palin “sticks up for the American people” and is the epitome of “freedom and liberty.” And yet, they have no arguments to back up their statements. This is what makes elections and campaigns so biased and unstable. Most voters get their information from newspaper and television shows. The news is biased to only show information which they feel is most important and these issues do not always coincide with the voters interests. The mainstream media plays a significant role in the information that is expressed to voters and this can affect the way we vote. This past election shows a great example of this ignorance and shortsightedness.
On Penn State campus, most voters were “following the trend” and intensely behind Barack Obama, yet if you had asked students various questions on the election, then they probably did not know any of his political stances. Most students just voted for him because the idea of Obama was engraved into their minds that everything they heard about him was thought to be the best idea any candidate could conceive. People follow the mainstream and insist on pursuing what everyone else is doing. It is disappointing that people fail to think for themselves and follow their own ideas. As stated, often people have “ideas that are different from those we espouse.” Because people are not thinking for themselves we are conforming to the mainstream and not sticking up for our own beliefs, if those even still exist. The one man on the video stated that American is “just another country” which is extremely offensive to think of the United States as losing its strength. But with everyone conforming to the same ideals, we are losing the basis of America which thrives on independence and freedom.
In my opinion, some people are afraid to have their own opinions because they are afraid of rejection. They must feel that if they just agree or take a back seat ride instead of standing up for themselves then they won’t be noticed for their opinions but this rejects the basic ideas of liberty. We have been conformed to such tight strings since early childhood that it may be hard for some people to deter from this. Yet it is very disheartening to think people are having “rusty thinking” and aren’t curious enough about issues to form their own opinions or conclusions.
[Reply]
While reading this post, I couldn’t help but stop and think, “Yeah, we really don’t have conversations with people around us.” Everyone’s minds are so stuck in high gear that we rarely take a second to stop and think about what we are actually saying. I know I do it. I’m already planning what to say next while I’m talking to someone else. I’m probably not even listening to what they are actually saying, and then again, are they even listening to me?
I believe our society is so caught up in technological and psychological demands that we are more robotic than anything else. We are programmed to follow social cues. But now when I reflect, I rarely see people exchange meaningful conversations or even act well mannered at that. It is pretty rare to see students hold the door for other students; maybe they do for elders but rarely for peers.
I have to be honest, I too find myself too worried about where I need to be or what I need to be doing, but I have taken some time to have real conversations lately. About a year ago, I started spending more and more time with a few girls from my hall. We would just hang out, get ready together, go eat at the Commons, you know the normal things friends would do. It’s pretty funny because whenever we would be eating over the weekend, we would always get into an hour long debate over something. We still do this all the time; it’s never forced or interrogating, just our thoughts on whatever comes up. And we have talked about everything; religion, politics, race, gender, homosexuality, how we feel about abortion. And we don’t always agree, but that’s what makes it fun.
I think what I’ve come to realize in all of this is that you probably really need to feel comfortable with people and confident in your perspective to engage in these types of conversations. I think that’s why we aren’t thinking, we are either too nervous to put our feelings out there too early in an interaction or we just never formed an opinion in the first place. It’s true, school doesn’t really teach you how to learn or think, and it’s pretty much expected. I want to be a teacher some day, yet school doesn’t really promote thought anymore. Education values accuracy and quantity over quality; I guess basically everything contradictory to what teachers say they want. So, what I get out of this is that I may not know more than those around me or even know the right answer, but I have been occupying my time with enough thought provoking conversations to keep my brain working and I hope that I can challenge my students to interact with one another and society in a similar way.
[Reply]
It is extremely unfortunate and disheartening, yet the honest truth, that this video was not at all surprising to me. This video is about far more than politics, but rather about the human brain and how people think and are so incapable of changing viewpoints when so set on something. The perfect description of this really is "the rusty brain". People, and yes, me included, fail to think. If people were to ask me what party I was , I would say democratic. I would also continue to say, that I would never vote for a Republican candidate, regardless of if they were better fit to lead our nation. I wouldn't even dare to consider voting for a Republican, and find a way to twist around everything they proposed in their campaigns to use it against them as candidates. My back up? I would say I disagree with what the Republican party stands for. (In all honesty, writing this and watching this video, what does that even mean?) However, if a Democrat were not as fit for a position as a Republican, I would never admit to it, due to my stubbornness and incapability, like many others, to actually think about my stance and viewpoints, and possibly have them changed would most likely never happen. But this lack of thinking, this lack of openness to change, and actually to extend even further, lack of experience, is what plagues our society.
This does not just effect politics, it effects social interactions, race relations, and even more specific things like advancement in school and personal and societal discovery. Our parents and/or guardians, families, teachers, and overall aspects of our environment affect how we view "our" world. We are raised to think about things one way or another. I think I am SUPPOSED to marry someone Jewish, because my mother has always told me so. This is the way it SUPPOSED to be, so that's the way I will try to make it. What about your earliest science classes? Your teacher stood up in front of the class and told you the earth was round. Anyone ever question a teacher? What about ask him or her to prove it? Chances are, your answer is no, because you're not SUPPOSED to question a teacher. What about a friend you've met here, at Penn State, who has never met a black person in their life, a person who comes from a small white country town? They are most likely, like many of the people I have met from these places, going to have a negative view of black people (overgeneralization or not) Regardless of if they meet someone and become great friends with a black person at Penn State, they will still hold a viewpoint of them regardless of if they realize it or not. Yes, many people may argue me on this, that a person's opinion can change. But that is not what I am saying. What I am saying is that views and "supposed to be's" are drilled into from our individual environments and we then develop views that we THINK have substantial support, yet how many times are our viewpoints even accurate? What's so wrong with branching out? What is so wrong with thinking? Chances are its fear; fear of change, fear of being wrong, fear of challenging what "is". It is lack of exposure, lack of experience. People need to open up a little more and look at the whole world, rather than the "one they live in".
[Reply]
I have no idea why many people, and personally me, do not know a lot about politics and current events. My lack of knowledge on everyday subjects really makes me feel stupid and embarrassed. As a well educated human being shouldn't I know about what is going on around me? Instead of discussing politics with others I simply do not give any opinion because I am afriad I will sound dumb and also because I feel like politics is such a touchy subject and I do not want to argue about it. Me being afraid of expressing my opinion, however, has led to me not exactly knowing how I feel. Ever since I was young I always took on my parent’s point of view as the “right” way to think without ever stopping to ask myself my own beliefs. Looking at it now I still cannot make my own decisions because I feel in order to make one I have to know all the facts. With all the technology out there today it is easy to get information on the latest events but sadly me, and most of my friends, do not even have the passion to take time to look at what is going on around us. I do feel that since I am an adult now I should be interested in our country’s policies however since I have never looked into it before it has been hard for me to get started. I really wish that I took the time to learn more about politics but I do not make it a priority and maybe that is beacuse I cannot see how it directly affects my family and friends as well as myself. When news is put in front of me I do take interest and feel good about being able to discuss and know what is going on when I hear the topic brought up. For example, as I was waiting to go into a meeting, CNN was on and they were discussing the Hati disaster. I found myself very interested in how these people were going to be helped, but at the same time when I turn on the television I turn right to MTV and skip over the news because I have a preconceived notion that news is boring. Personally, I would think there was something wrong with me for the fact that I rather watch snookie being punched than hear about the new health plan, except most other people I know and hang out with do the exact same thing. So is it possible that my generation just was never taught to take interest, or is it merely the environment that I was brought up in? My parents, however, are always talking about the latest discovery or wildly arguing about their health care policies. Maybe it is the fact that because my parents take care of everything and understand what is going on I have not had to think for myself or even learned how. Growing up in a small neighborhood I have never been tested or questioned why things are the way they are. I feel as if I have a lack of experience in life and even though I was "well educated" during high school I learned nothing about life in general even with all the resources I have been given.
[Reply]
I think that the You Tube video says it all. Does anyone really think that
people in this country are elected to public office by a knowing and well
informed electorate? We live in a world of sound bites. It is rare for our
candidates to be forthright in their positions and similarly uncommon for
our television journalists to inform us properly of the contender's thinking
on the issues. Whether the zealous advocate is a Palin fan or an Obama
follower most people only know buzz words or repeat what they have heard
over the most recent news cycle. Because so many voters tend to be one
issue advocates it is no surprise that "rusty" rules the world. Abortion,
war, the economy, jobs, taxes…take your pick. A perceived understanding
regarding a candidate's position on only one of these emotional issues will
usually generate support and a vote. Why bother to think more than one has
to. Power to the people.
[Reply]